Green Daniel J, Thomas Hannah J, Marsh Channa E, Lester Leanne, Naylor Louise H, Haynes Andrew
School of Human Sciences (Exercise and Sport Science), The University of Western Australia, Perth, Western Australia, Australia.
Business School (Centre for Social Impact), The University of Western Australia, Perth, Western Australia, Australia.
J Physiol. 2025 Mar;603(5):1045-1056. doi: 10.1113/JP287534. Epub 2025 Feb 6.
Exercise has direct and indirect anti-atherogenic impacts on arterial function and health in humans. Few studies have directly compared the impacts of different commonly adopted exercise approaches on femoral artery function. We hypothesized that, owing to its direct impact via sustained increases in shear stress, endurance (END) training would have larger impacts on arterial diameter and function than resistance (RES) training. Thirty-nine young, healthy participants (age 26.9 ± 6.2 years, 22♀) completed 12 weeks of both RES and END training in random order, separated by a 12 week washout. Resting femoral artery diameter and flow-mediated dilatation (FMD) were collected before and after each exercise intervention. END training was associated with an increase in both FMD (Δ1.61 ± 3.09%, P = 0.005) and resting diameter (Δ0.15 ± 0.29 mm, P = 0.004). Neither resting diameter nor FMD increased following RES. However, sex difference analysis revealed that males increased FMD following RES (Δ2.21 ± 3.76%, P = 0.015), whereas no RES change was evident for females. Following END, both males and females increased FMD (♂, Δ1.11 ± 1.65%; ♀, Δ1.88 ± 3.67%; both P = 0.025), with males also showing an increase in resting arterial diameter following END (Δ0.23 ± 0.2 mm, P < 0.001). Group data revealed that END has greater impacts than RES on femoral artery diameter and flow-mediated functional responses, which are endothelium mediated and nitric oxide dependent. Males exhibit beneficial impacts in response to both END and RES, whereas females respond predominantly to END. Our findings suggest that arterial adaptation to exercise might be influenced by exercise modality and sex. KEY POINTS: Exercise has anti-atherogenic effects and lowers the risk of cardiovascular diseases. This is mediated, in part, by the direct haemodynamic impacts of exercise on arterial function, structure and health. Different modalities of exercise have distinct effects on arterial haemodynamics, but few studies have directly compared, within subjects and using a cross-over design of trial, the relative impacts of distinct forms of exercise training on arterial adaptation. In this study, endurance training increased baseline femoral artery diameter and flow-mediated dilatation, which is endothelium dependent and mediated by nitric oxide. Resistance training had a beneficial but lesser impact. Females and males were responsive to endurance training, but only males responded positively to resistance training in this study. These results show that changing the training mode modifies training-induced arterial adaptation; this has implications for the optimization of exercise prescription for individual benefit.
运动对人体动脉功能和健康具有直接和间接的抗动脉粥样硬化作用。很少有研究直接比较不同常用运动方式对股动脉功能的影响。我们推测,由于耐力(END)训练通过持续增加剪切应力产生直接影响,因此与阻力(RES)训练相比,其对动脉直径和功能的影响更大。39名年轻健康参与者(年龄26.9±6.2岁,22名女性)以随机顺序完成了12周的RES和END训练,中间间隔12周的洗脱期。在每次运动干预前后收集静息股动脉直径和血流介导的扩张(FMD)数据。END训练与FMD增加(Δ1.61±3.09%,P = 0.005)和静息直径增加(Δ0.15±0.29 mm,P = 0.004)相关。RES训练后静息直径和FMD均未增加。然而,性别差异分析显示,男性RES训练后FMD增加(Δ2.21±3.76%,P = 0.015),而女性无明显变化。END训练后,男性和女性的FMD均增加(男性,Δ1.11±1.65%;女性,Δ1.88±3.67%;P均 = 0.025),男性END训练后静息动脉直径也增加(Δ0.23±0.2 mm,P < 0.001)。分组数据显示,END训练对股动脉直径和血流介导的功能反应的影响大于RES训练,这些反应是内皮介导且依赖一氧化氮的。男性对END和RES训练均有有益反应,而女性主要对END训练有反应。我们的研究结果表明,动脉对运动的适应性可能受运动方式和性别的影响。要点:运动具有抗动脉粥样硬化作用,可降低心血管疾病风险。这部分是由运动对动脉功能、结构和健康的直接血流动力学影响介导的。不同运动方式对动脉血流动力学有不同影响,但很少有研究在受试者内部采用交叉试验设计直接比较不同形式运动训练对动脉适应性的相对影响。在本研究中,耐力训练增加了基线股动脉直径和血流介导的扩张,后者是内皮依赖性且由一氧化氮介导的。阻力训练有有益作用,但影响较小。女性和男性对耐力训练均有反应,但在本研究中只有男性对阻力训练有积极反应。这些结果表明,改变训练模式可改变训练诱导的动脉适应性;这对优化运动处方以实现个体受益具有重要意义。