中国大陆偏头痛治疗患者教育在线视频资源的质量与可靠性:一项基于电子媒体的研究
The quality and reliability of online video resources concerning patient education for migraine treatment in China Mainland: an electronic media-based study.
作者信息
Ge Rongguang, Xu Xiuman, Chen Yunhao, You Shoujiang, Xu Jiaping, Dai Haoyi, Huang Wenqi, Sun Hongpeng, Cao Yongjun, Chang Jie
机构信息
Department of Neurology and Clinical Research Centre of Neurological Disease, The Second Affiliated Hospital of Soochow University, 1055 Sanxiang Road, Suzhou, 215004, China.
Department of Occupational and Environmental Health, School of Public Health, Suzhou Medical College, Soochow University, 199 Renai Road, Suzhou, 215123, China.
出版信息
BMC Public Health. 2025 Feb 18;25(1):656. doi: 10.1186/s12889-025-21861-x.
BACKGROUND
Migraine is an extremely prevalent and disabling primary neurological disease worldwide. Although multiple forms of patient education for migraine management have been employed in the past decades, the quality and reliability of headache-related online videos targeting migraine patients remained unclear, particularly those in China. Therefore, in this study, our research team aimed to explore the overall quality and credibility of online videos concerning patient education on migraine treatment in China Mainland.
METHODS
A total of 182 online videos concerning migraine treatment were retrieved from four most popular Chinese language online video platforms, including Douyin, BiliBili, Haokan Video, and Xigua Video. Our research team collected the producer identity and basic information of these videos, and then used two major score instruments, i.e., the Global Quality Score (GQS) scale and the DISCERN questionnaire, to evaluate the quality and reliability of its content. Subsequently, overall descriptive analysis and detailed comparison among specific video platforms and producers were performed. Finally, using the Spearman correlation coefficient, we also explored the potential correlation between video general information and video quality and reliability.
RESULTS
The overall quality and reliability of the migraine-related information provided by online videos were poor, yet those uploaded to Douyin were relatively more satisfactory. Among all study videos, 10 encouraged patients to keep a headache diary, 12 warned about the risk of medication overuse, and 32 emphasized the preventive treatment of chronic migraine. However, the treatment recommendations proposed by video creators were highly heterogenous, with the most frequently mentioned pharmacological, non-pharmacological, and traditional Chinese medicine measures being Triptans (n = 57, 31.3%), massage (n = 40, 22.0%), and acupuncture (n = 31, 17.0%), respectively. We also observed slight positive correlations between video quality and the numbers of likes and comments received.
CONCLUSIONS
The results of our research revealed that the quality and reliability of Chinese language online videos focused on patient education for migraine treatment were inadequate, suggesting that viewers should treat these contents with caution. However, the prospects for video-based patient education remain promising. Implementing appropriate strategies, such as strengthening regulations on health-related videos and instituting a review process conducted by medical professionals, may elevate the overall quality and trustworthiness of medical information shared through online video platforms.
背景
偏头痛是一种在全球范围内极为普遍且使人丧失能力的原发性神经系统疾病。尽管在过去几十年中已采用多种形式的偏头痛管理患者教育方法,但针对偏头痛患者的头痛相关在线视频的质量和可靠性仍不明确,在中国尤其如此。因此,在本研究中,我们的研究团队旨在探索中国大陆有关偏头痛治疗患者教育的在线视频的整体质量和可信度。
方法
从四个最受欢迎的中文在线视频平台,包括抖音、哔哩哔哩、好看视频和西瓜视频,共检索到182个关于偏头痛治疗的在线视频。我们的研究团队收集了这些视频的创作者身份和基本信息,然后使用两个主要评分工具,即全球质量评分(GQS)量表和DISCERN问卷,来评估其内容的质量和可靠性。随后,进行了总体描述性分析以及特定视频平台和创作者之间的详细比较。最后,使用斯皮尔曼相关系数,我们还探讨了视频一般信息与视频质量和可靠性之间的潜在相关性。
结果
在线视频提供的偏头痛相关信息的整体质量和可靠性较差,但上传到抖音的视频相对更令人满意。在所有研究视频中,10个鼓励患者记录头痛日记,12个警告药物过度使用的风险,32个强调慢性偏头痛的预防性治疗。然而,视频创作者提出的治疗建议高度异质,最常提及的药物、非药物和中医措施分别是曲坦类药物(n = 57,31.3%)、按摩(n = 40,22.0%)和针灸(n = 31,17.0%)。我们还观察到视频质量与获得的点赞数和评论数之间存在轻微正相关。
结论
我们的研究结果表明,专注于偏头痛治疗患者教育的中文在线视频的质量和可靠性不足,这表明观众应谨慎对待这些内容。然而,基于视频的患者教育前景依然广阔。实施适当的策略,如加强对健康相关视频的监管并建立由医学专业人员进行的审查流程,可能会提高通过在线视频平台分享的医疗信息的整体质量和可信度。