Westman M, Eden D, Shirom A
Soc Sci Med. 1985;20(6):637-44. doi: 10.1016/0277-9536(85)90402-2.
Relationships between questionnaire measures of job stress and smoking intensity (SI) and cessation were studied among 560 disease-free smoking males and 310 quitters all members of 22 kibbutzim. The main-effect hypothesis that stress is positively related to SI and negatively to cessation received some support in correlational and multiple regression analyses for the entire sample. Hours of work, work addiction, lack of influence, intrinsic impoverishment and lack of support were positively associated with SI. Conflict, responsibility, hours of work, low status, lack of influence and harsh working conditions were negatively associated with cessation. When peer support was dichotomized into low and high, we found that persons reporting low support smoked significantly more than those who reported high support. Seeking effects of both hours of work and support on SI, we found additive main effects but no interaction effect. The average number of cigarettes smoked by people who worked less than 8 hours and reported high support was 17, whereas people who worked more than 8 hours and reported low support smoked an average of 22 cigarettes a day. The buffering effect of support on the relationship between stress and both SI and cessation of smoking was examined by means of interaction analysis. No buffer effect was evident for SI. However, for respondents reporting low support more job stressors were negatively related to cessation than among those reporting high support, confirming the support-buffer hypothesis. Suggestions regarding better measurement of support are discussed. We conclude with the hypothesis that social support may be detrimental to the smoker, depending on the smoking attitudes and behaviors of the 'supportive' others.
在22个基布兹的所有成员中,对560名无疾病的吸烟男性和310名戒烟者进行了问卷调查,研究工作压力与吸烟强度(SI)及戒烟之间的关系。压力与SI呈正相关、与戒烟呈负相关这一主效应假设在对整个样本的相关分析和多元回归分析中得到了一些支持。工作时长、工作成瘾、缺乏影响力、内在匮乏和缺乏支持与SI呈正相关。冲突、责任、工作时长、地位低下、缺乏影响力和恶劣的工作条件与戒烟呈负相关。当将同伴支持分为低和高两类时,我们发现报告低支持的人比报告高支持的人吸烟量显著更多。在研究工作时长和支持对SI的影响时,我们发现了相加的主效应,但没有交互效应。工作时长少于8小时且报告高支持的人平均每天吸烟17支,而工作时长超过8小时且报告低支持的人平均每天吸烟22支。通过交互分析检验了支持对压力与SI及戒烟之间关系的缓冲效应。对于SI没有明显的缓冲效应。然而,对于报告低支持的受访者,与报告高支持的受访者相比,更多的工作压力源与戒烟呈负相关,这证实了支持缓冲假设。讨论了关于更好地测量支持的建议。我们最后提出一个假设,即社会支持可能对吸烟者有害,这取决于“支持性”他人的吸烟态度和行为。