Lisonbee Rich J, Peterson Andrew C, Lenz Amy L
Department of Orthopaedics, University of Utah, Salt Lake City, USA.
Department of Biomedical Engineering, University of Utah, Salt Lake City, UT, USA.
Comput Methods Biomech Biomed Engin. 2025 Mar 20:1-16. doi: 10.1080/10255842.2025.2478527.
Evaluations of 3D joint space measurements between study groups have traditionally relied on surface regional divisions, which attenuate the impact of shape on joint measurements. Advancements in morphometric analyses have enabled evaluation of population-based shape variations as they relate to disease progression and deformity. Specifically, correspondence model-based shape analyses offer co-registered landmarks that address shape variability in joint structures and can be utilized for comparison of joint space measurements. This study proposes a method using correspondence models to perform group-wise statistical analyses in static or quasi-static positions during movement, offering a more comprehensive assessment of joint space variability. The primary objective was to verify and validate the measurement methods of a developed open-source toolbox. Testing was performed with surface meshes of varying edge length (0.5-, 1-, and 2-mm) and with different expected joint space distances (1- and 4-mm). Validation testing of accuracy revealed <1% error for 0.5- and 1-mm mesh edge lengths for 4 mm joint space, sensitivity testing demonstrated best results for 0.5 mm edge length, and repeatable/reliable measurements yielded low coefficient of variation and high intraclass correlation coefficient. These findings support the use of correspondence model-based approaches for robust and accurate analysis of joint measurements related to anatomical features. This method addresses limitations in traditional techniques by incorporating shape variability, providing a practical tool for assessing joint-level disease and deformity. Future work will focus on evaluating the application of this approach in diverse clinical scenarios, including highly deformed joint structures.
传统上,研究组之间三维关节间隙测量的评估依赖于表面区域划分,这减弱了形状对关节测量的影响。形态计量分析的进展使得能够评估与疾病进展和畸形相关的基于人群的形状变化。具体而言,基于对应模型的形状分析提供了共同配准的地标,可解决关节结构中的形状变异性,并可用于比较关节间隙测量。本研究提出了一种使用对应模型在运动过程中的静态或准静态位置进行组间统计分析的方法,从而对关节间隙变异性进行更全面的评估。主要目的是验证和确认一个已开发的开源工具箱的测量方法。使用不同边长(0.5毫米、1毫米和2毫米)的表面网格以及不同的预期关节间隙距离(1毫米和4毫米)进行测试。精度验证测试显示,对于4毫米关节间隙,0.5毫米和1毫米网格边长的误差<1%,灵敏度测试表明0.5毫米边长的结果最佳,可重复/可靠测量产生低变异系数和高组内相关系数。这些发现支持使用基于对应模型的方法对与解剖特征相关的关节测量进行稳健而准确的分析。该方法通过纳入形状变异性解决了传统技术的局限性,为评估关节水平的疾病和畸形提供了一个实用工具。未来工作将集中评估该方法在包括高度变形关节结构在内的各种临床场景中的应用。