Skubera Magda, Korbmacher Max, Evans Thomas Rhys, Azevedo Flavio, Pennington Charlotte R
School of Psychology, Aston University, Birmingham, UK.
Mohn Medical Imaging and Visualisation Centre, Bergen, Norway.
R Soc Open Sci. 2025 Mar 19;12(3):241726. doi: 10.1098/rsos.241726. eCollection 2025 Mar.
Concerns about the replicability, reproducibility and transparency of research have ushered in a set of practices and behaviours under the umbrella of 'open research'. To this end, many new initiatives have been developed that represent procedural (i.e. behaviours and sets of commonly used practices in the research process), structural (new norms, rules, infrastructure and incentives), and community-based change (working groups, networks). The objectives of this research were to identify and outline international initiatives that enhance awareness and uptake of open research practices in the discipline of psychology. A systematic mapping review was conducted in three stages: (i) a Web search to identify open research initiatives in psychology; (ii) a literature search to identify related articles; and (iii) a hand search of grey literature. Eligible initiatives were then coded into an overarching theme of procedural, structural or community-based change. A total of 187 initiatives were identified; 30 were procedural (e.g. toolkits, resources, software), 70 structural (e.g. policies, strategies, frameworks) and 87 community-based (e.g. working groups, networks). This review highlights that open research is progressing at pace through various initiatives that share a common goal to reform research culture. We hope that this review promotes their further adoption and facilitates coordinated efforts between individuals, organizations, institutions, publishers and funders.
对研究的可重复性、再现性和透明度的担忧催生了一系列以“开放研究”为框架的实践和行为。为此,人们制定了许多新举措,这些举措涵盖程序方面(即研究过程中常用的行为和实践集)、结构方面(新规范、规则、基础设施和激励措施)以及基于社区的变革(工作组、网络)。本研究的目的是识别并概述提高心理学学科对开放研究实践的认识和采用率的国际举措。我们分三个阶段进行了系统的映射综述:(i)通过网络搜索识别心理学领域的开放研究举措;(ii)通过文献搜索识别相关文章;(iii)人工搜索灰色文献。然后,将符合条件的举措编码为程序变革、结构变革或基于社区的变革这一总体主题。共识别出187项举措;其中30项是程序方面的(如工具包、资源、软件),70项是结构方面的(如政策、策略、框架),87项是基于社区的(如工作组、网络)。本综述强调,开放研究正在通过各种有着改革研究文化这一共同目标的举措快速发展。我们希望本综述能促进这些举措的进一步采用,并推动个人、组织、机构、出版商和资助者之间的协同努力。