Vazquez Lydia, Muresan Anna, Zarauz Cristina
Department of Orofacial Rehabilitation, University Clinics of Dental Medicine (CUMD), University of Geneva, 1211 Geneva, Switzerland.
Barras & Associates, Avenue de France 6, 1950 Sion, Switzerland.
Diagnostics (Basel). 2025 Apr 2;15(7):911. doi: 10.3390/diagnostics15070911.
: Rectangular collimation (RC) reduces patient radiation exposure but is uncommonly used due to cone-cut concerns. An audit at a dental practice was conducted to analyze impact of RC on the quality of intraoral radiographs. : Four X-ray tubes with RC were used. 360 intraoral X-rays were collected, blinded and scored to pre-set qualitative criteria: maximum 14 points for bitewing radiographs (BWs), and 13 for periapical radiographs (PAs). Quality of the X-rays was assessed. : We found that 48.1% were acceptable, 32.5% were unacceptable and only 19.4% were good X-rays. The loss of image quality was unrelated to RC. Three cone-cuts occurred in PAs without RC. The mean scores for PAs performed without or with RC were as follows: 9.3 ± 1.9 points and 9.6 ± 1.9 points, respectively ( = 0.166). The mean scores for BWs performed without or with RC were as follows: 8.0 ± 1.9 points and 7.1 ± 1.9 points, respectively ( < 0.001). All scores declined over time. : This audit highlighted the need for refresher training on film-holder use and the importance of regular maintenance of dental X-ray equipment. Decline in X-ray quality over time was related to wear and tear of X-ray equipment, incorrect image contrast, and technical errors unrelated to RC. No cone-cuts occurred when using RC.
矩形准直(RC)可减少患者的辐射暴露,但由于担心出现锥形切割伪影,其使用并不常见。在一家牙科诊所进行了一项审计,以分析矩形准直对口腔内X光片质量的影响。使用了四个带有矩形准直的X光管。收集了360张口腔内X光片,在不知情的情况下按照预先设定的定性标准进行评分:咬合翼片(BW)最高14分,根尖片(PA)最高13分。对X光片的质量进行了评估。我们发现48.1%的片子可接受,32.5%不可接受,只有19.4%是高质量的X光片。图像质量的下降与矩形准直无关。在没有矩形准直的根尖片中出现了三次锥形切割伪影。有无矩形准直情况下拍摄的根尖片的平均得分如下:分别为9.3±1.9分和9.6±1.9分(P = 0.166)。有无矩形准直情况下拍摄的咬合翼片的平均得分如下:分别为8.0±1.9分和7.1±1.9分(P < 0.001)。所有得分都随时间下降。这项审计强调了对胶片夹使用进行再培训的必要性以及定期维护牙科X光设备的重要性。X光片质量随时间下降与X光设备的磨损、不正确的图像对比度以及与矩形准直无关的技术错误有关。使用矩形准直时未出现锥形切割伪影。