Santa Ramírez Hugo-Alejandro, Ramírez-Giraldo Andrés-Felipe, Pilkington Hugo, Borrell Carme, Otálvaro-Castro Gabriel-Jaime
Faculty of Medicine, Institute of Global Health, University of Geneva, 1202 Geneva, Switzerland.
Health Policies and Management Research Group, National Faculty of Public Health, Universidad de Antioquia, Medellín 050010, Colombia.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2025 Apr 1;22(4):537. doi: 10.3390/ijerph22040537.
Deprivation indices are used to monitor health inequities. However, their theoretical underpinnings have been based on the context of Western industrialized countries, which have distinct social and historical backgrounds compared to Latin America and the Caribbean and countries in the Global South. Following the Latin American Social Determination of Health perspective, particularly the category Modes of Living supported by the construct of precarity, we aimed to develop an index of precarity in the modes of living at the department level in Colombia and assess its geographical distribution and potential value for public health. We conducted an ecological cross-sectional study with national administrative records. We developed a precarity index through Principal Component Analysis and performed spatial autocorrelation analyses and regression models with child mortality indicators. Our final index comprised twenty indicators representing four dimensions of the modes of living and power relations. We found precarity not to distribute randomly in Colombia, with a center-periphery divide and higher precarity observed in the country's margin. We also found an association of our index with under-five mortality (SMR = 1.19; 95%CI 1.08-1.31) and infant mortality (SMR = 1.13; 95%CI 1.00-1.26). Our index highlights the relevance of considering the modes of living when devising deprivation indices or similar measures from Colombia or Latin America. This approach may provide different perspectives on the health-disease process and potential value for public health planning.
贫困指数用于监测健康不平等状况。然而,其理论基础一直基于西方工业化国家的背景,与拉丁美洲、加勒比地区以及全球南方国家相比,这些国家有着独特的社会和历史背景。遵循拉丁美洲健康社会决定因素的观点,特别是由不稳定状况这一概念所支撑的生活方式类别,我们旨在编制哥伦比亚各部门层面的生活方式不稳定指数,并评估其地理分布以及对公共卫生的潜在价值。我们利用国家行政记录开展了一项生态横断面研究。我们通过主成分分析编制了一个不稳定指数,并对儿童死亡率指标进行了空间自相关分析和回归模型分析。我们的最终指数包含二十个指标,代表了生活方式和权力关系的四个维度。我们发现不稳定状况在哥伦比亚并非随机分布,存在中心 - 外围的划分,且在该国边缘地区观察到更高的不稳定程度。我们还发现我们的指数与五岁以下儿童死亡率(标准化死亡比 = 1.19;95%置信区间 1.08 - 1.31)和婴儿死亡率(标准化死亡比 = 1.13;95%置信区间 1.00 - 1.26)存在关联。我们的指数凸显了在编制哥伦比亚或拉丁美洲的贫困指数或类似衡量标准时考虑生活方式的相关性。这种方法可能为健康 - 疾病过程提供不同视角,并对公共卫生规划具有潜在价值。