Milkie Melissa A, Sayer Liana C, Nomaguchi Kei, Yan Hope Xu
University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada.
University of Maryland, College Park, MD, USA.
Socius. 2025 Jan-Dec;11. doi: 10.1177/23780231251314667. Epub 2025 Feb 6.
Gender scholars have debated whether the recent movement toward a more equal division of domestic labor is stalling. Using a differential convergence perspective, the authors argue that examining which domestic tasks undergo gender convergence, whose changes narrow the gap, and why changes happen is critical for understanding gender inequalities in unpaid labor time. Using data from the 2003-2023 American Time Use Survey, the authors examine trends in total housework (including core and occasional housework), shopping, and childcare time. Results for married individuals indicate that the historically large gender gap in total housework time narrowed further this century, from a women-to-men ratio of 1.8:1 in 2003-2005 to 1.6:1 in 2022-2023. This shrinking of the gender gap was concentrated in traditionally feminine core housework (decreasing by 40 percent, from 4.2:1 to 2.5:1), particularly housecleaning and laundry. The gender difference in shopping time also narrowed, nearing parity. For childcare time, the gender gap shrunk from 2:1 to 1.8:1, though this change was not statistically significant. Decomposition analyses indicate that women's reduced housework time was explained mainly by population compositional shifts, whereas men's increased core housework time likely reflected behavioral or normative changes. With men taking on more female-typed domestic activities, the gendered norms associated with different forms of unpaid labor may be becoming redefined.
性别研究学者们一直在争论,最近家庭劳动分工朝着更加平等的方向发展的趋势是否正在停滞。作者们运用差异趋同视角认为,考察哪些家务劳动出现了性别趋同、哪些人的变化缩小了差距以及变化为何发生,对于理解无偿劳动时间方面的性别不平等至关重要。作者们利用2003年至2023年美国时间使用调查的数据,研究了总家务劳动(包括核心家务和偶尔家务)、购物和育儿时间的趋势。已婚人士的研究结果表明,本世纪以来,总家务劳动时间上历来巨大的性别差距进一步缩小,从2003年至2005年的女性与男性比例1.8:1降至2022年至2023年的1.6:1。性别差距的缩小集中在传统上由女性承担的核心家务上(下降了40%,从4.2:1降至2.5:1),尤其是清洁和洗衣。购物时间上的性别差异也缩小了,接近持平。在育儿时间方面,性别差距从2:!缩小到1.8:1,不过这一变化在统计上并不显著。分解分析表明,女性家务劳动时间的减少主要是由人口构成变化来解释的,而男性核心家务劳动时间的增加可能反映了行为或规范的变化。随着男性承担更多女性化的家务活动,与不同形式无偿劳动相关的性别规范可能正在被重新定义。