Suhas Morgane, Abisset-Chavanne Emmanuelle, Rey Pierre-André
Univ. Bordeaux, CNRS, Bordeaux INP, I2M, UMR 5295, F-33400 Talence, France.
Arts et Metiers Institute of Technology, CNRS, Bordeaux INP, I2M, UMR 5295, F-33400 Talence, France.
Sensors (Basel). 2025 Mar 20;25(6):1952. doi: 10.3390/s25061952.
Failure monitoring of industrial systems is imperative in order to ensure their reliability and competitiveness. This paper presents an innovative hybrid modelling approach applied to DC electric motors, specifically the Kollmorgen AKM42 servomotor. The proposed Cooperative Hybrid Model for Classification (CHMC) combines physics-based and data-driven models to improve fault detection and extrapolation to new usage profiles. The integration of physical knowledge of the healthy behaviour of the motor into a recurrent neural network enhances the accuracy of bearing fault detection by identifying three health states: healthy, progressive fault and stabilised fault. Additionally, Singular Value Decomposition (SVD) is employed for the purposes of feature extraction and dimensionality reduction, thereby enhancing the model's capacity to generalise with limited training data. The findings of this study demonstrate that a reduction in the input data of 90% preserves the essential information, with an analysis of the first harmonics revealing a narrow frequency range. This elucidates the reason why the first 20 components are sufficient to explain the data variability. The findings reveal that, for usage profiles analogous to the training data, both the CHMC and NHMC models demonstrate comparable performance without reduction. However, the CHMC model exhibits superior performance in detecting true negatives (90% vs. 89%) and differentiating between healthy and failure states. The NHMC model encounters greater difficulty in distinguishing failure states (83.92% vs. 86.56% for progressive failure). When exposed to new usage profiles with increased frequency and amplitude, the CHMC model adapts better, showing superior performance in detecting true positives and handling new data, highlighting its superior extrapolation capabilities. The integration of SVD further reduces input data complexity, and the CHMC model consistently outperforms the NHMC model in these reduced data scenarios, demonstrating the efficacy of combining physical models and dimensionality reduction in enhancing the model's generalisation, fault detection, and adaptability. This approach has the advantage of reducing the need for retraining, which makes the CHMC model a cost-effective solution for motor fault classification in industrial settings. In conclusion, the CHMC model offers a generalisable method with significant advantages in fault detection, model adaptation, and predictive maintenance performance across varying usage profiles and on unseen operational scenarios.
为确保工业系统的可靠性和竞争力,对其进行故障监测至关重要。本文提出了一种创新的混合建模方法,应用于直流电动机,特别是科尔摩根AKM42伺服电机。所提出的分类协作混合模型(CHMC)将基于物理的模型和数据驱动的模型相结合,以改进故障检测并外推到新的使用情况。将电机健康行为的物理知识集成到递归神经网络中,通过识别三种健康状态:健康、渐进故障和稳定故障,提高了轴承故障检测的准确性。此外,奇异值分解(SVD)用于特征提取和降维,从而增强了模型在有限训练数据下的泛化能力。本研究结果表明,输入数据减少90%仍能保留基本信息,对一次谐波的分析揭示了一个狭窄的频率范围。这阐明了前20个分量足以解释数据变异性的原因。研究结果表明,对于与训练数据类似的使用情况,CHMC和NHMC模型在不进行降维时表现出相当的性能。然而,CHMC模型在检测真阴性(90%对89%)以及区分健康状态和故障状态方面表现出卓越性能。NHMC模型在区分故障状态方面遇到更大困难(渐进故障为83.92%对86.56%)。当暴露于频率和幅度增加的新使用情况时,CHMC模型适应性更好,在检测真阳性和处理新数据方面表现出卓越性能,突出了其卓越的外推能力。SVD的集成进一步降低了输入数据的复杂性,在这些减少数据的情况下,CHMC模型始终优于NHMC模型,证明了结合物理模型和降维在增强模型泛化、故障检测和适应性方面的有效性。这种方法具有减少重新训练需求的优点,这使得CHMC模型成为工业环境中电机故障分类的经济有效解决方案。总之,CHMC模型提供了一种可泛化的方法,在不同使用情况和未见操作场景下的故障检测、模型适应性和预测性维护性能方面具有显著优势。