Zhong Hai, Zhao Yuan, Zhang Yumeng
Second Hospital of Shandong University, Jinan, China.
Shandong University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Jinan, China.
Abdom Radiol (NY). 2025 May 13. doi: 10.1007/s00261-025-04984-y.
To evaluate the possibility of performing renal vessel reconstruction on non-enhanced CT images using deep learning models.
177 patients' CT scans in the non-enhanced phase, arterial phase and venous phase were chosen. These data were randomly divided into the training set (n = 120), validation set (n = 20) and test set (n = 37). In training set and validation set, a radiologist marked out the right renal arteries and veins on non-enhanced CT phase images using contrast phases as references. Trained deep learning models were tested and evaluated on the test set. A radiologist performed renal vessel reconstruction on the test set without the contrast phase reference, and the results were used for comparison. Reconstruction using the arterial phase and venous phase was used as the gold standard.
Without the contrast phase reference, both radiologist and model could accurately identify artery and vein main trunk. The accuracy was 91.9% vs. 97.3% (model vs. radiologist) in artery and 91.9% vs. 100% in vein, the difference was insignificant. The model had difficulty identify accessory arteries, the accuracy was significantly lower than radiologist (44.4% vs. 77.8%, p = 0.044). The model also had lower accuracy in accessory veins, but the difference was insignificant (64.3% vs. 85.7%, p = 0.094).
Deep learning models could accurately recognize the right renal artery and vein main trunk, and accuracy was comparable to that of radiologists. Although the current model still had difficulty recognizing small accessory vessels, further training and model optimization would solve these problems.
评估使用深度学习模型在非增强CT图像上进行肾血管重建的可能性。
选取177例患者在非增强期、动脉期和静脉期的CT扫描数据。这些数据被随机分为训练集(n = 120)、验证集(n = 20)和测试集(n = 37)。在训练集和验证集中,一名放射科医生以增强期图像为参考,在非增强CT期图像上标记出右肾动脉和静脉。对训练好的深度学习模型在测试集上进行测试和评估。一名放射科医生在无增强期参考的情况下对测试集进行肾血管重建,并将结果用于比较。以动脉期和静脉期重建作为金标准。
在无增强期参考的情况下,放射科医生和模型均能准确识别动脉和静脉主干。动脉识别准确率分别为91.9%(模型)和97.3%(放射科医生),静脉识别准确率分别为91.9%和100%,差异无统计学意义。模型在识别副动脉方面存在困难,准确率显著低于放射科医生(44.4% vs. 77.8%,p = 0.044)。模型在识别副静脉方面的准确率也较低,但差异无统计学意义(64.3% vs. 85.7%,p = 0.094)。
深度学习模型能够准确识别右肾动脉和静脉主干,准确率与放射科医生相当。虽然当前模型在识别小的副血管方面仍存在困难,但进一步训练和模型优化将解决这些问题。