van der Merwe Ilze, Erasmus Petro, de Klerk Werner
School of Psychosocial Health, Faculty of Health Sciences, North-West University, Potchefstroom, South Africa.
Afr J Psychol Assess. 2024 May 20;6:148. doi: 10.4102/ajopa.v6i0.148. eCollection 2024.
This qualitative research study emerged from the essential need for reliable and valid intelligence test instruments for South African school learners, who are characterised as a diverse population with their variety in culture, ethnicity, and language, as well as having unequal socio-economic and educational backgrounds. The aim of this research study was to use a qualitative interpretive description research design to explore and describe the experiences of both experts in intelligence test development and/or adaptation as well as psychologists and psychometrists who have administered intelligence tests to South African school learners in various contexts. Twelve psychologists and/or psychometrists were interviewed, of which six were also experts in test development and/or adaptation, which yielded four themes after thematic analysis, namely, utilised intelligence measurements in the current South African school learner context are less relevant; the South African education system is a major issue specifically within lower socio-economic status (SES) contexts; it does not seem feasible to design or adapt suitable intelligence measures that are valid and reliable in the current South African school learner context; and key informants' recommendations from their experiences.
This research study contributes to the understanding of the measurement of intelligence of South African school learners in diverse contexts. Findings of this research study can guide the strategic process to design an intelligence instrument suitable for a South African population of school learners, informing fair assessment practices for multiethnic equalisation.
这项定性研究源于对南非学校学习者可靠且有效的智力测试工具的迫切需求。南非学校学习者群体具有多样性,其文化、种族和语言各不相同,社会经济和教育背景也不平等。本研究旨在采用定性解释性描述研究设计,探索并描述智力测试开发和/或改编专家以及在不同情境下对南非学校学习者进行智力测试的心理学家和心理测量师的经历。研究采访了12位心理学家和/或心理测量师,其中6位也是测试开发和/或改编方面的专家。经过主题分析,得出了四个主题,即当前南非学校学习者背景下所使用的智力测量方法相关性较低;南非教育系统是一个主要问题,在社会经济地位较低的背景下尤为突出;在当前南非学校学习者背景下设计或改编有效且可靠的合适智力测量方法似乎不可行;以及关键信息提供者根据自身经验提出的建议。
本研究有助于理解不同背景下南非学校学习者的智力测量情况。本研究的结果可为设计适合南非学校学习者群体的智力工具的战略过程提供指导,为多民族平等化的公平评估实践提供参考。