Rego Ryan T, Reneau Kyrani, Zhukov Yuri, Rice Kristina, Brady Patrick, Siwo Geoffrey, Kollman Ken, Odero Sabina, Mokaya Mercy, Abubakar Amina, Pienta Amy, Waljee Akbar K
Center for Global Health Equity, Michigan Medicine, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan, USA.
Clinton Health Access Initiative, Boston, Massachusetts, USA.
J Glob Health. 2025 May 23;15:04066. doi: 10.7189/jogh.15.04066.
The large amount of data on COVID-19 vaccination hesitancy presents a unique opportunity to better understand COVID-19 vaccination uptake. However, the utility of this data is unclear, particularly how representative the surveys are of general populations, how easy the data is to use, and how valid the outcome (intent to be vaccinated) is. We explored this in the World Bank's high frequency phone surveys (HFPS).
The HFPS were conducted longitudinally in over 50 countries between 2020-21. A subset of the HFPS contained questions on vaccination hesitancy. We compared the demographic results from four surveys against the most recent census to determine the representativeness of the sample and vaccination intent/actual vaccination against government-reported vaccination rates.
While the surveys were generally representative of population sizes and the rural/urban split, they tended to over-sample men and older people and omitted several key indicators. We also found that self-reported vaccination rates were higher than actual vaccination rates.
It is important to consider challenges in the HFPS data and other datasets which measure vaccination acceptance by phone surveys. It is also important to consider the ease of data use. However, even when these challenges arise, there are still opportunities for meaningful use of the data.
关于新冠疫苗接种犹豫的大量数据为更好地了解新冠疫苗接种情况提供了独特契机。然而,这些数据的效用尚不清楚,尤其是调查对普通人群的代表性如何、数据使用的难易程度如何以及结果(接种意愿)的有效性如何。我们在世界银行的高频电话调查(HFPS)中对此进行了探究。
2020年至2021年期间,在50多个国家纵向开展了高频电话调查。高频电话调查的一个子集中包含了有关疫苗接种犹豫的问题。我们将四项调查的人口统计结果与最新的人口普查进行比较,以确定样本的代表性以及接种意愿/实际接种情况与政府报告的疫苗接种率的对比情况。
虽然这些调查总体上能够代表人口规模和城乡分布,但往往对男性和老年人进行了过度抽样,并且遗漏了几个关键指标。我们还发现,自我报告的疫苗接种率高于实际接种率。
重要的是要考虑高频电话调查数据以及其他通过电话调查衡量疫苗接种接受情况的数据集所面临的挑战。考虑数据使用的便利性也很重要。然而,即使出现这些挑战,仍然存在有意义地使用这些数据的机会。