Dulal-Arthur T, Hassard J, Wang W, Yarker J, Thomson L, Blake H
Schools of Medicine & Health Sciences, University of Nottingham, Nottingham, UK, NG7 2UH.
Queen's Business School, Queen's University Belfast, Belfast, UK, BT9 5EE.
Occup Med (Lond). 2025 Jul 14;75(3):188-195. doi: 10.1093/occmed/kqaf028.
Work-related stress is a growing concern in the UK, negatively impacting both employee well-being and organizational effectiveness. Addressing work-related stress through effective managerial practices is essential, however, existing tools are often lengthy and impractical for routine use.
The study aimed to develop and validate a shortened version of the 36-item Stress Management Competency Indicator Tool (SMCIT) to enhance its practicality and relevance to changing working practices, while maintaining reliability and validity in assessing stress management competencies.
A secondary data analysis was undertaken using data from 224 line managers across 12 organizations. Principle component analysis was applied to reduce the SMCIT from 36 to 19 items. Psychometric analysis, including Cronbach's alpha, factor loadings and total variance explained, was used to ensure the shortened tool retained its measurement rigour.
The 19-item SMCIT retained four latent constructs: respectful/ responsible, managing the individual within the team, conflict/problem management and organizational resources. The revised tool explained 46% of the variance, compared to 37% for the original, and showed factor loadings ranging from point 0.43 to 0.86. Reliability scores ranged from 0.65 to 0.69, indicating moderate internal consistency. We conclude that the shortened tool enhances measurement efficiency by removing redundant items, while maintaining key competencies.
The shortened SMCIT is a reliable and practical tool for evaluating line management competencies, reducing response burden while improving data quality and relevance to hybrid working. We recommend further validation through confirmatory factor analysis and expert review to enhance its application in occupational settings.
工作压力在英国日益受到关注,对员工福祉和组织效能均产生负面影响。通过有效的管理实践来应对工作压力至关重要,然而,现有的工具通常冗长且不适合日常使用。
本研究旨在开发并验证36项压力管理能力指标工具(SMCIT)的简化版,以提高其实用性,并使其与不断变化的工作实践相关,同时在评估压力管理能力时保持可靠性和有效性。
使用来自12个组织的224名直线经理的数据进行二次数据分析。应用主成分分析将SMCIT从36项减少到19项。采用包括克朗巴哈系数、因子载荷和解释的总方差在内的心理测量分析,以确保简化后的工具保持其测量严谨性。
19项的SMCIT保留了四个潜在结构:尊重/负责、在团队中管理个人、冲突/问题管理和组织资源。修订后的工具解释了46%的方差,而原始工具为37%,因子载荷范围为0.43至0.86。可靠性得分在0.65至0.69之间,表明内部一致性适中。我们得出结论:简化后的工具通过去除冗余项目提高了测量效率,同时保持了关键能力。
简化后的SMCIT是评估直线管理能力的可靠实用工具,减轻了回答负担,同时提高了数据质量以及与混合工作的相关性。我们建议通过验证性因子分析和专家评审进行进一步验证,以增强其在职业环境中的应用。