Zimmermann Elizabeth, Tomczyk Samuel
Department Health and Prevention, Institute of Psychology, University of Greifswald, Greifswald, Germany.
German Center for Child and Adolescent Health (DZKJ), partner site Greifswald/Rostock, Greifswald, Germany.
J Med Internet Res. 2025 Jun 9;27:e71510. doi: 10.2196/71510.
Social media offers promising, low-cost, and accessible ways to promote adolescent health within their daily routines. Platforms such as Instagram engage users through interactive features-including quizzes, question stickers, and polls-that encourage participation and behavior change. However, risks such as addiction potential and exposure to harmful content highlight the need for carefully designed interventions.
This study aims to explore adolescents' preferences and needs for Instagram-based health promotion to inform the design of our life skill intervention, "leduin (Lebenskompetent durch Instagram)," which means "life skills through Instagram."
Following a qualitative approach, we organized 12 semistructured interviews and focus groups with 67 adolescents aged between 14 and 17 years (women: n=37, 55%; men: n=29, 43%; and nonbinary: n=1, 2%), recruited via Instagram advertisements and from schools in Germany. We conducted 5 school-based focus groups (grammar school: n=1, 20%; Montessori school: n=2, 40%; and special education school: n=2, 40%) and 2 web-based focus groups. In addition, 5 individual interviews with boys were carried out to balance gender representation, as boys were less vocal in group settings. Data were analyzed using content analysis with a combined deductive-inductive coding approach in MAXQDA software, achieving high intercoder reliability (Cohen κ=0.93). The study design followed co-design principles, the social media uses and gratifications theory, and a cultural sensitivity framework.
Adolescents valued Instagram for social connection, personal growth, and engaging content, but some felt these programs might resemble schoolwork or attract only those already interested. To improve engagement, adolescents suggested combining intrinsic motivation (authentic connections) with extrinsic incentives, such as vouchers or praise. Adolescents recommended that health programs be visually engaging, interactive, and personalized, ideally featuring peers for better relatability. Posts and reels were popular for concise information, especially when using short, subtitled reels with engaging captions. However, the advertisements were disliked. Immersive, brief stories were appreciated, with interactive features, such as quizzes, polls, and question stickers, being valued for their brevity, curiosity appeal, and anonymity. Adolescents found live videos less appealing, citing logistical issues and a lack of structure, reflecting a preference for asynchronous content. Comments were rarely used due to privacy concerns, though some saw their potential for engaging with friends. Furthermore, most adolescents did not like notifications and switched them off.
Findings support the social media uses and gratifications theory, highlighting the value of interactive and culturally sensitive content. While the small, region-specific sample limits generalizability, it reflects the depth of qualitative inquiry. Although social desirability and teacher presence may have influenced responses, efforts to foster openness aimed to minimize such effects. Instagram shows promise for adolescent health promotion through interactive, visually engaging, and culturally relevant content. Future research should explore broader and more diverse participant profiles to improve generalizability.
社交媒体提供了在青少年日常生活中促进其健康的有前景、低成本且易于使用的方式。Instagram等平台通过互动功能(包括测验、问题贴纸和投票)吸引用户,鼓励参与和行为改变。然而,诸如成瘾风险和接触有害内容等问题凸显了精心设计干预措施的必要性。
本研究旨在探索青少年对基于Instagram的健康促进的偏好和需求,为我们的生活技能干预措施“leduin(通过Instagram实现生活能力)”的设计提供参考,该措施意为“通过Instagram培养生活技能”。
采用定性研究方法,我们通过Instagram广告和从德国学校招募了12个半结构化访谈和焦点小组,共有67名年龄在14至17岁之间的青少年参与(女性:n = 37,55%;男性:n = 29,43%;非二元性别:n = 1,2%)。我们开展了5个基于学校的焦点小组(文理中学:n = 1,20%;蒙台梭利学校:n = 2,40%;特殊教育学校:n = 2,40%)和2个基于网络的焦点小组。此外,还对男孩进行了5次个人访谈以平衡性别代表性,因为男孩在小组环境中发言较少。使用MAXQDA软件中的内容分析法,采用演绎 - 归纳相结合的编码方法对数据进行分析,编码者间信度较高(Cohen κ = 0.93)。该研究设计遵循共同设计原则、社交媒体使用与满足理论以及文化敏感性框架。
青少年重视Instagram在社交联系、个人成长和引人入胜的内容方面的作用,但有些人认为这些项目可能类似于功课,或者只吸引那些已经感兴趣的人。为了提高参与度,青少年建议将内在动机(真实的联系)与外在激励措施相结合,如优惠券或表扬。青少年建议健康项目在视觉上具有吸引力、互动性强且个性化,理想情况下有同龄人参与以增强共鸣。帖子和短视频很受欢迎,因为它们能提供简洁的信息,特别是当使用带有吸引人字幕的简短带字幕短视频时。然而,广告不受欢迎。沉浸式的简短故事受到赞赏,带有测验、投票和问题贴纸等互动功能因其简洁性、激发好奇心和匿名性而受到重视。青少年认为直播视频吸引力较小,理由是存在后勤问题且缺乏结构,这反映出他们对异步内容的偏好。由于隐私问题,评论很少被使用,尽管有些人看到了其与朋友互动的潜力。此外,大多数青少年不喜欢通知并将其关闭。
研究结果支持社交媒体使用与满足理论,凸显了互动性和文化敏感内容的价值。虽然小范围、特定地区的样本限制了普遍性,但它反映了定性研究的深度。尽管社会期望和教师在场可能影响了回答,但为促进开放性所做的努力旨在尽量减少此类影响。Instagram通过互动性强、视觉上有吸引力且与文化相关的内容,在促进青少年健康方面显示出前景。未来的研究应探索更广泛、更多样化的参与者特征,以提高普遍性。