Tortosa-La Osa Silvia, Esteo Alcalá María Victoria, Martín-Ruiz Eva, Olry de Labry-Lima Antonio
Improving Economies for Stronger Communities (IESC). Santo Domingo. República Dominicana.
Doctorado Interuniversitario en Ciencias de la Salud; Universidad de Sevilla. Sevilla. España.
Rev Esp Salud Publica. 2025 Jun 5;99:e202506028.
It is estimated that more that 80% of world´s population live in areas at risk from at least one major vector-borne disease, being mosquitoes responsible for a significant disease burden. Given that biological control is a more natural option compared to other available interventions and that the use of fish is widespread, the aim of this review was to analyze the effectiveness of fish-based interventions to control mosquito-borne diseases.
A bibliographic search was conducted through PubMed, Embase, Cochrane, LILACS, WOS-Core Collection and CAB Abstracts for observational or experimental studies published in English, Spanish, or Portuguese up to December 2023. The outcome variables of interest were entomological and epidemiological indicators.
Of the 2,227 references identified, seven articles were ultimately included. All studies measured the impact using entomological indicators, while only two also used epidemiological indicators. The interventions involved the release of fish into domestic water containers, rice fields, and excavations or wells linked to a canal construction. All studies observed a significant reduction in both entomological and epidemiological indicators. The larval reduction ranged between 80% and 100%, while the reduction in clinical cases reached 99.87%.
The release of fish leads to a meaningful reduction in both larval indicators and clinical cases. However, it is necessary to assess whether large-scale fish releases are feasible, sustainable, cost-effective, and sufficient to achieve vector control, as well as to consider the potential negative impact of their introduction into a given ecosystem.
据估计,世界上超过80%的人口生活在至少面临一种主要媒介传播疾病风险的地区,蚊子是造成重大疾病负担的原因。鉴于与其他可用干预措施相比,生物防治是一种更自然的选择,且鱼类的使用很广泛,本综述的目的是分析基于鱼类的干预措施对控制蚊媒疾病的有效性。
通过PubMed、Embase、Cochrane、LILACS、WOS核心合集和CAB文摘库进行文献检索,查找截至2023年12月以英文、西班牙文或葡萄牙文发表的观察性或实验性研究。感兴趣的结果变量是昆虫学和流行病学指标。
在识别出的2227篇参考文献中,最终纳入了7篇文章。所有研究都使用昆虫学指标衡量影响,而只有两项研究也使用了流行病学指标。干预措施包括将鱼放入家庭储水容器、稻田以及与运河建设相关的挖掘处或水井中。所有研究都观察到昆虫学和流行病学指标均显著降低。幼虫减少率在80%至100%之间,临床病例减少率达到99.87%。
放鱼可使幼虫指标和临床病例显著减少。然而,有必要评估大规模放鱼是否可行、可持续、具有成本效益且足以实现病媒控制,同时要考虑将鱼引入特定生态系统可能产生的负面影响。