Brigo Francesco
Innovation, Research and Teaching Service, Teaching Hospital of the Paracelsus Medical Private University (PMU), Azienda Sanitaria DellAlto Adige, Bolzano-Bozen, Italy.
Neurol Sci. 2025 Jun 19. doi: 10.1007/s10072-025-08302-8.
During his lessons, Jean-Martin Charcot (1825-1893) explored the role of dreams in neurological and psychiatric conditions. While often overshadowed by Sigmund Freud's later contributions, Charcot's observations provide valuable insights into the intersection of neurology and dream analysis. Charcot identified characteristic dream patterns linked to specific conditions: aggressive animal dreams in hysteria, recurrent traumatic nightmares in traumatic neurosis, auditory hallucinations in chronic alcoholism, and enhanced motor imagery in phantom limb syndrome. Conversely, he viewed the lack of dreams, as seen in the condition later termed Charcot-Wilbrand syndrome, as a significant clinical aspect. His observations extended beyond somatic symptoms to incorporate the psychological aspects of patients' experiences. Charcot even considered the possibility that, in some cases, nightmares could act as significant factors in the development of hysteria, highlighting the complex interplay between the mind and body in this condition. Although grounded in a positivist framework, Charcot's work demonstrated a willingness to explore subjective dream content, aligning with his broader clinical-anatomical correlation method. This article re-evaluates Charcot's contributions to dream research, arguing that his work, though often overlooked, played a foundational role in shaping early scientific discussions on the relationship between dreams, pathology, and the nervous system.
在他的课程中,让-马丁·沙可(1825 - 1893)探讨了梦在神经和精神疾病中的作用。虽然沙可的贡献常常被西格蒙德·弗洛伊德后来的成就所掩盖,但他的观察为神经学与梦的分析的交叉领域提供了宝贵的见解。沙可识别出与特定疾病相关的特征性梦的模式:癔症中的攻击性动物梦、创伤性神经症中的反复创伤性噩梦、慢性酒精中毒中的幻听,以及幻肢综合征中增强的运动意象。相反,他认为后来被称为沙可-威尔布兰德综合征的病症中缺乏梦是一个重要的临床特征。他的观察不仅限于躯体症状,还纳入了患者经历的心理方面。沙可甚至考虑到在某些情况下,噩梦可能是癔症发展的重要因素,这凸显了这种病症中心灵与身体之间复杂的相互作用。尽管沙可的工作基于实证主义框架,但他愿意探索主观的梦的内容,这与他更广泛的临床-解剖学相关方法相一致。本文重新评估了沙可对梦的研究的贡献,认为他的工作虽然常常被忽视,但在塑造关于梦、病理学和神经系统之间关系的早期科学讨论中起到了基础性作用。