Bustamante-Miranda Arelmys, Aguilar-Vásquez Eduardo, Ramos-Olmos Miguel, Rojas-Flores Segundo, González-Delgado Ángel Darío
Chemical Engineering Department, Nanomaterials and Computer Aided Process Engineering Research Group (NIPAC), Universidad de Cartagena, Cartagena 130015, Colombia.
Business Administration Department, Grupo de Investigación en Ciencias Administrativas y Seguridad y Salud en el Trabajo (CIASST), Universidad Minuto de Dios-UniMinuto, Cartagena 130001, Colombia.
Polymers (Basel). 2025 Jun 13;17(12):1639. doi: 10.3390/polym17121639.
Water regeneration in PVC production is a key issue to consider, given the high freshwater consumption rate of the process. This research evaluates the inherent safety of poly(vinyl chloride) (PVC) production via suspension polymerization by implementing mass and energy integration strategies in combination with wastewater regeneration under a zero-liquid-discharge (ZLD) approach. The impact of these integrations on process safety was examined by considering the risks associated with the handling of hazardous materials and critical operations, as well as the reduction in waste generation. To this end, the Inherent Safety Index (ISI) methodology was employed, which quantifies hazards based on factors such as toxicity and flammability, enabling the identification of risks arising from system condition changes due to the implementation of sustainable water treatment technologies. Although the ISI methodology has been applied to various chemical processes, there are few documented cases of its specific application in PVC plants that adopt circular production strategies and water resource sustainability. Therefore, in this study, ISI was used to thoroughly evaluate each stage of the process, providing a comprehensive picture of the safety risks associated with the use of sustainable technologies. The assessment was carried out using simulation software, computer-aided process engineering (CAPE) methodologies, and information obtained from safety repositories and expert publications. Specifically, the Chemical Safety Index score was 22 points, with the highest risk associated with flammability, which scored 4 points, followed by toxicity (5 points), explosiveness (2 points), and chemical interactions, with 4 points attributed to vinyl chloride monomer (VCM). In the toxicity sub-index, both VCM and PVC received 5 points, while substances such as sodium hydroxide (NaOH) and sodium chloride (NaCl) scored 4 points. In the heat of reaction sub-index, the main reaction scored 3 points due to its high heat of reaction (-1600 kJ/kg), while the secondary reactions from PVA biodegradation scored 0 points for the anoxic reaction (-156.5 kJ/kg) and 3 points for the aerobic reaction (-2304 kJ/kg), significantly increasing the total index. The Process Safety Index scored 15 points, with the highest risk found in the inventory of hazardous substances within the inside battery limits (ISBL) of the plant, where a flow rate of 3241.75 t/h was reported (5 points). The safe equipment sub-index received 4 points due to the presence of boilers, burners, compressors, and reactors. The process structure scored 3 points, temperature 2, and pressure 1, reflecting the criticality of certain operating conditions. Despite sustainability improvements, the process still presented significant chemical and operational risks. However, the implementation of control strategies and safety measures could optimize the process, balancing sustainability and safety without compromising system viability.
鉴于聚氯乙烯(PVC)生产过程中淡水消耗率较高,水的再生是一个需要考虑的关键问题。本研究通过实施质量和能量集成策略,并结合零液体排放(ZLD)方法下的废水再生,评估了悬浮聚合法生产聚氯乙烯(PVC)的固有安全性。通过考虑与危险材料处理和关键操作相关的风险以及废物产生的减少,研究了这些集成对过程安全的影响。为此,采用了固有安全指数(ISI)方法,该方法基于毒性和可燃性等因素对危害进行量化,从而能够识别由于实施可持续水处理技术而导致系统条件变化所产生的风险。尽管ISI方法已应用于各种化学过程,但在采用循环生产策略和水资源可持续性的PVC工厂中,其具体应用的记录案例很少。因此,在本研究中,ISI被用于全面评估该过程的每个阶段,提供了与使用可持续技术相关的安全风险的全貌。评估使用了模拟软件、计算机辅助过程工程(CAPE)方法以及从安全知识库和专家出版物中获得的信息。具体而言,化学安全指数得分为22分,其中与可燃性相关的风险最高,得4分,其次是毒性(5分)、爆炸性(2分)和化学相互作用,氯乙烯单体(VCM)的化学相互作用得4分。在毒性子指数中,VCM和PVC均得5分,而氢氧化钠(NaOH)和氯化钠(NaCl)等物质得4分。在反应热子指数中,主反应因其较高的反应热(-1600 kJ/kg)得3分,而聚乙烯醇生物降解的副反应在缺氧反应(-156.5 kJ/kg)中得0分,但在好氧反应(-2304 kJ/kg)中得3分,显著提高了总指数。过程安全指数得15分,在工厂内界区(ISBL)的有害物质存量方面风险最高,据报告流量为3241.75 t/h(5分)。由于存在锅炉、燃烧器、压缩机和反应器,安全设备子指数得4分。过程结构得3分,温度得2分,压力得1分,反映了某些操作条件的关键性。尽管可持续性有所改善,但该过程仍存在重大的化学和操作风险。然而,实施控制策略和安全措施可以优化该过程,在不影响系统可行性的情况下平衡可持续性和安全性。