Li Yalei, Cai Xu, Liu Yinzhao, Jia Liping, Lu Guohua
Department of Public Health, Shandong Second Medical University, Weifang, China.
Department of Psychosomatic Medicine, Shandong Daizhuang Hospital, Jining, China.
Front Psychiatry. 2025 Jun 13;16:1496519. doi: 10.3389/fpsyt.2025.1496519. eCollection 2025.
The present study aimed to investigate the effects of reward and punishment on inhibitory control in the alcohol use disorder (AUD) group and healthy control group.
Eighteen male patients with AUD and twenty-one age- and education-matched male healthy controls were recruited for the study. Participants engaged in the two-choice oddball paradigm, which included reward, punishment, and neutral conditions. Participants were asked to respond differently to standard and deviant stimuli as accurately and quickly as possible.
For reaction time measures, deviant - standard difference of the healthy control group did not show any difference; however, deviant - standard difference of the AUD group was significantly larger in the reward condition than in the neutral condition. For accuracy measures, deviant - standard difference of the healthy control group did not show any difference; however, deviant - standard difference of the AUD group was significantly larger in the neutral condition than in the reward condition, indicating a greater decline in accuracy for deviant stimuli.
Our findings demonstrated that either reward nor punishment effectively enhanced inhibitory control in AUD patients. Notably, the reward condition was associated with a further decline in inhibitory control. It is advisable to avoid relying solely on reward- or punishment-based behavioral correction strategies, as they might heighten psychological stress and negative emotions, potentially worsening deficits in inhibitory control.
本研究旨在调查奖励和惩罚对酒精使用障碍(AUD)组和健康对照组抑制控制的影响。
招募了18名患有AUD的男性患者和21名年龄及教育程度匹配的男性健康对照者参与本研究。参与者进行二选一奇偶数范式实验,该实验包括奖励、惩罚和中性条件。要求参与者尽可能准确、快速地对标准刺激和偏差刺激做出不同反应。
在反应时间测量方面,健康对照组的偏差 - 标准差异没有显示出任何差异;然而,AUD组在奖励条件下的偏差 - 标准差异显著大于中性条件。在准确性测量方面,健康对照组的偏差 - 标准差异没有显示出任何差异;然而,AUD组在中性条件下的偏差 - 标准差异显著大于奖励条件,这表明偏差刺激的准确性下降幅度更大。
我们的研究结果表明,奖励和惩罚均未有效增强AUD患者的抑制控制。值得注意的是,奖励条件与抑制控制的进一步下降有关。建议避免仅依赖基于奖励或惩罚的行为矫正策略,因为它们可能会加剧心理压力和负面情绪,从而可能使抑制控制缺陷恶化。