Sahin Fatih, Menekse Akin
Department of Software Engineering, Istanbul Topkapi University, 34087, Istanbul, Turkey.
Istanbul Technical University, 34467, Istanbul, Turkey.
Sci Rep. 2025 Jul 1;15(1):21505. doi: 10.1038/s41598-025-07852-3.
Internal control is a set of procedures, policies, and processes established within an organization with the aim of reasonably ensuring the accomplishment of the organization's objectives. As businesses confront a more intricate and ever-changing environment, the importance of reliable methodologies capable of effectively dealing with uncertainties and ambiguities becomes crucial. Given the potential complexity arising from numerous criteria, candidates, and the inherent subjectivity introduced by multiple decision experts participating in the process, evaluating internal control risk can be conceptualized as a problem within fuzzy multi-criteria decision-making (MCDM). Criteria Importance Through Inter-criteria Correlation (CRITIC) integrated Evaluation based on distance from average solution (EDAS) methodology is developed for addressing internal control risk assessment. The proposed methodology is presented in an interval-valued spherical fuzzy environment for modeling the uncertainty of the decision-making process in a comprehensive manner. Internal control evaluation criteria are obtained from the enterprise risk management framework presented by the Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission (COSO). The study contributes significantly by prioritizing internal control levels, conducting sensitivity analyses, and providing a comparative analysis with contemporary approaches. The paper structures a comprehensive review of literature, outlines mathematical operations of interval-valued spherical fuzzy sets, details the proposed methodology, and presents application results with theoretical and practical implications. The manuscript concludes by acknowledging limitations and suggesting avenues for future research, offering a valuable resource for professionals and researchers in the field of internal control and audit.
内部控制是组织内部建立的一套程序、政策和流程,旨在合理确保组织目标的实现。随着企业面临更加复杂和不断变化的环境,能够有效应对不确定性和模糊性的可靠方法的重要性变得至关重要。鉴于众多标准、候选方案以及参与该过程的多个决策专家所引入的固有主观性可能产生的复杂性,内部控制风险评估可被概念化为模糊多准则决策(MCDM)中的一个问题。基于离差最大化的准则重要性通过准则间相关性(CRITIC)集成评估方法被开发出来用于解决内部控制风险评估问题。所提出的方法在区间值球面模糊环境中呈现,以全面模拟决策过程的不确定性。内部控制评估标准取自特雷德韦委员会(COSO)发起组织委员会提出的企业风险管理框架。该研究通过对内部控制水平进行优先级排序、进行敏感性分析以及与当代方法进行比较分析做出了重大贡献。本文对文献进行了全面综述,概述了区间值球面模糊集的数学运算,详细介绍了所提出的方法,并给出了具有理论和实践意义的应用结果。本文通过承认局限性并提出未来研究的途径来得出结论,为内部控制和审计领域的专业人员和研究人员提供了宝贵的资源。