Singh Veena Kumari, Singh Shruti, Tiwari Meenakshi, Haq Ansarul, Sharma Sarsij, Moudgil Tania
Department of Burns & Plastic Surgery, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, Patna, Bihar, India.
Department of Pharmacology, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, Patna, Bihar, India.
BMC Med Educ. 2025 Jul 1;25(1):865. doi: 10.1186/s12909-025-07355-9.
Health professionals often encounter challenges in systematic problem-solving due to biases, heuristics, inflexible mindsets, and limited critical thinking (CT) capabilities. This could potentially result in compromised patient care. This study aimed to develop a module to foster critical thinking skills in postgraduate (PG) trainees, measure its impact on enhancing their CT knowledge, and evaluate their satisfaction with the module.
A structured CT module was developed based on literature review and expert opinion. The CT knowledge of 52 first-year PGs was evaluated through Google Forms before and after implementing the module. The enhancement in CT proficiency was assessed using the Holistic Critical Thinking Scoring Rubric (HCTSR) after the course. The post-course feedback included pertinent enquiries regarding their satisfaction with the course and suggestions for refining the course content and delivery.
The study demonstrated improvement in the CT knowledge as shown by the median knowledge score of PGs which improved from 17/27 to 23/27 (p-value < 0.05). According to the HCTSR assessment, 69.2% of students improved their CT ability (4/5) upon completing the course. Most students (84.6%) provided feedback indicating that they felt confident applying CT skills in their future personal and professional decision-making.
The research underscored that a structured foundation course for PGs can serve to sensitize them to critical thinking. At this point, focus should be given to refining teaching strategies and creating environments conducive to CT in healthcare.
Not applicable.
由于存在偏见、启发式思维、僵化的思维模式以及有限的批判性思维(CT)能力,卫生专业人员在系统解决问题时常常面临挑战。这可能会对患者护理产生不利影响。本研究旨在开发一个模块,以培养研究生(PG)学员的批判性思维技能,衡量其对提升学员CT知识的影响,并评估他们对该模块的满意度。
基于文献综述和专家意见开发了一个结构化的CT模块。在实施该模块前后,通过谷歌表单对52名一年级PG学员的CT知识进行了评估。课程结束后,使用整体批判性思维评分量表(HCTSR)评估CT熟练程度的提高情况。课程结束后的反馈包括有关他们对课程满意度的相关询问,以及对完善课程内容和授课方式的建议。
研究表明PG学员的CT知识有所提高,PG学员的知识得分中位数从17/27提高到23/27(p值<0.05)。根据HCTSR评估,69.2%的学生在完成课程后提高了CT能力(4/5)。大多数学生(84.6%)提供的反馈表明,他们对在未来个人和职业决策中应用CT技能感到自信。
该研究强调,为PG学员开设的结构化基础课程可以促使他们对批判性思维产生敏感认识。此时,应注重改进教学策略,并营造有利于医疗保健领域批判性思维的环境。
不适用。