Eshelman School of Pharmacy, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Chapel Hill, North Carolina.
Associate Editor, American Journal of Pharmaceutical Education, Arlington, Virginia.
Am J Pharm Educ. 2019 Mar;83(2):7033. doi: 10.5688/ajpe7033.
To review the importance of and barriers to critical thinking and provide evidence-based recommendations to encourage development of these skills in pharmacy students. Critical thinking (CT) is one of the most desired skills of a pharmacy graduate but there are many challenges to students thinking critically including their own perceptions, poor metacognitive skills, a fixed mindset, a non-automated skillset, heuristics, biases and the fact that thinking is effortful. Though difficult, developing CT skills is not impossible. Research and practice suggest several factors that can improve one's thinking ability: a thoughtful learning environment, seeing or hearing what is done to executive cognitive operations that students can emulate, and guidance and support of their efforts until they can perform on their own. Teaching CT requires coordination at the curricular level and further to the more discrete level of a lesson and a course. Instructor training is imperative to this process since this intervention has been found to be the most effective in developing CT skills.
回顾批判性思维的重要性和障碍,并提供循证建议,以鼓励药学学生发展这些技能。批判性思维(CT)是药学毕业生最需要的技能之一,但学生批判性思维存在许多挑战,包括他们自己的认知、元认知技能差、固定思维模式、非自动化技能、启发式、偏见以及思维费力的事实。尽管困难重重,但培养 CT 技能并非不可能。研究和实践表明,有几个因素可以提高一个人的思维能力:深思熟虑的学习环境、观察或听到学生可以模仿的执行认知操作,以及对他们努力的指导和支持,直到他们能够独立完成。教授 CT 需要在课程层面上进行协调,并且进一步需要在课程和课程的更离散层面上进行协调。教师培训对于这个过程至关重要,因为这种干预措施被发现是培养 CT 技能最有效的方法。