Cao Fang, Zhao Pingshan, Lin Yi, Xu Xiren, Guan Zheng, Ma Yanqing
Department of Radiology, Affiliated People's Hospital, Zhejiang Provincial People's Hospital, Hangzhou Medical College, Hangzhou, 310014, Zhejiang, China.
Department of Radiology, Shaoxing Hospital of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Shaoxing, Zhejiang, China.
BMC Med Educ. 2025 Jul 1;25(1):971. doi: 10.1186/s12909-025-07576-y.
The precise evaluation of pulmonary nodules via computed tomography (CT) is pivotal in clinical decision-making and patient prognosis. Artificial intelligence (AI)-assisted target reconstruction technology for pulmonary nodules can more clearly display the target nodule and its relationship with surrounding structures, aiding radiologists in higher diagnostic accuracy. Nevertheless, few studies have examined the impact of such AI-based software on the education and training of residents. This study aims to investigate the role of AI-assisted pulmonary nodule target reconstruction software in enhancing the diagnostic capabilities of residents from different specialties and to explore differences between three different learning modes, thereby preliminarily assessing the significance of AI technology in clinical training of medical imaging for residents.
Seventy-five standardized training residents from various specialties, including 32 radiology and 43 non-radiology residents, participated in rotations in our radiology department between August 2020 and September 2023. Following a four-week period of training and learning with AI-assisted pulmonary nodule target reconstruction software and the traditional picture archiving and communication system (PACS), the diagnostic capabilities of both radiology and non-radiology residents in evaluating pulmonary nodule cases were assessed. Additionally, the differences in their ability to assess and diagnose pulmonary nodules under three distinct learning modes assisted by AI software (full-application, cross-application, and interval-application) were analyzed.
After four weeks of training, the diagnostic accuracy of radiology residents for five test pulmonary nodule cases ranged from 96.88 to 100%, outperforming non-radiology residents, whose accuracy ranged from 67.44 to 86.04%. Among the 54 residents trained under three predefined learning modes, significant differences were found in pulmonary nodule assessment scores. Pairwise comparisons using the Tukey-Kramer test revealed that the full-application group scored lower compared to both the cross-application ( = 0.002) and interval-application ( = 0.004) groups, with the latter two demonstrating superior performance.
AI-assisted target reconstruction and assessment software for pulmonary nodules is found to be valuable in medical imaging education and training. A hybrid learning approach that integrates AI software with traditional PACS may be more effective in enhancing the pulmonary nodule assessment and diagnostic capabilities of residents.
通过计算机断层扫描(CT)对肺结节进行精确评估在临床决策和患者预后中起着关键作用。人工智能(AI)辅助的肺结节目标重建技术能够更清晰地显示目标结节及其与周围结构的关系,有助于放射科医生提高诊断准确性。然而,很少有研究探讨这种基于AI的软件对住院医师教育和培训的影响。本研究旨在调查AI辅助的肺结节目标重建软件在提高不同专业住院医师诊断能力方面的作用,并探索三种不同学习模式之间的差异,从而初步评估AI技术在医学影像住院医师临床培训中的意义。
2020年8月至2023年9月期间,75名来自不同专业的规范化培训住院医师,包括32名放射科住院医师和43名非放射科住院医师,在我们放射科参加轮转。在使用AI辅助的肺结节目标重建软件和传统的图像存档与通信系统(PACS)进行为期四周的培训和学习后,评估放射科和非放射科住院医师评估肺结节病例的诊断能力。此外,分析了他们在AI软件辅助的三种不同学习模式(全应用、交叉应用和间隔应用)下评估和诊断肺结节能力的差异。
经过四周的培训,放射科住院医师对5例测试肺结节病例的诊断准确率在96.88%至100%之间,优于非放射科住院医师,后者的准确率在67.44%至86.04%之间。在按照三种预定义学习模式培训的54名住院医师中,肺结节评估分数存在显著差异。使用Tukey-Kramer检验进行两两比较发现,全应用组的得分低于交叉应用组(=0.002)和间隔应用组(=0.004),后两组表现更优。
发现AI辅助的肺结节目标重建与评估软件在医学影像教育和培训中有价值。将AI软件与传统PACS相结合的混合学习方法可能在提高住院医师肺结节评估和诊断能力方面更有效。