Krag Christian Hedeager, Müller Felix Christoph, Gandrup Karen Lind, Andersen Michael Brun, Møller Jakob Møllenbach, Liu Marie Louise, Rud Anita, Krabbe Simon, Al-Farra Lamaa, Nielsen Mads, Kruuse Christina, Boesen Mikael Ploug
Department of Radiology, University Hospital Copenhagen-Herlev and Gentofte, Copenhagen, Denmark.
Faculty of Health and Medical Sciences, University of Copenhagen, Copenhagen, Denmark.
Eur Radiol. 2025 Jul 15. doi: 10.1007/s00330-025-11807-7.
To assess the prevalence of motion artifacts and the factors associated with them in a cohort of suspected stroke patients, and to determine their impact on diagnostic accuracy for both AI and radiologists.
This retrospective cross-sectional study included brain MRI scans of consecutive adult suspected stroke patients from a non-comprehensive Danish stroke center between January and April 2020. An expert neuroradiologist identified acute ischemic, hemorrhagic, and space-occupying lesions as references. Two blinded radiology residents rated MRI image quality and motion artifacts. The diagnostic accuracy of a CE-marked deep learning tool was compared to that of radiology reports. Multivariate analysis examined associations between patient characteristics and motion artifacts.
775 patients (68 years ± 16, 420 female) were included. Acute ischemic, hemorrhagic, and space-occupying lesions were found in 216 (27.9%), 12 (1.5%), and 20 (2.6%). Motion artifacts were present in 57 (7.4%). Increasing age (OR per decade, 1.60; 95% CI: 1.26, 2.09; p < 0.001) and limb motor symptoms (OR, 2.36; 95% CI: 1.32, 4.20; p = 0.003) were independently associated with motion artifacts in multivariate analysis. Motion artifacts significantly reduced the accuracy of detecting hemorrhage. This reduction was greater for the AI tool (from 88 to 67%; p < 0.001) than for radiology reports (from 100 to 93%; p < 0.001). Ischemic and space-occupying lesion detection was not significantly affected.
Motion artifacts are common in suspected stroke patients, particularly in the elderly and patients with motor symptoms, reducing accuracy for hemorrhage detection by both AI and radiologists.
Question Motion artifacts reduce the quality of MRI scans, but it is unclear which factors are associated with them and how they impact diagnostic accuracy. Findings Motion artifacts occurred in 7% of suspected stroke MRI scans, associated with higher patient age and motor symptoms, lowering hemorrhage detection by AI and radiologists. Clinical relevance Motion artifacts in stroke brain MRIs significantly reduce the diagnostic accuracy of human and AI detection of intracranial hemorrhages. Elderly patients and those with motor symptoms may benefit from a greater focus on motion artifact prevention and reduction.
评估疑似中风患者队列中运动伪影的患病率及其相关因素,并确定其对人工智能(AI)和放射科医生诊断准确性的影响。
这项回顾性横断面研究纳入了2020年1月至4月期间来自丹麦一家非综合性中风中心的连续成年疑似中风患者的脑部MRI扫描。一位神经放射学专家将急性缺血性、出血性和占位性病变作为参考标准。两名不知情的放射科住院医师对MRI图像质量和运动伪影进行评分。将一款获得CE标志的深度学习工具的诊断准确性与放射学报告的诊断准确性进行比较。多变量分析研究了患者特征与运动伪影之间的关联。
共纳入775例患者(年龄68岁±16岁,女性420例)。发现急性缺血性、出血性和占位性病变的患者分别有216例(27.9%)、12例(1.5%)和20例(2.6%)。存在运动伪影的患者有57例(7.4%)。多变量分析显示,年龄增长(每十岁的比值比为1.60;95%置信区间:1.26,2.09;p<0.001)和肢体运动症状(比值比为2.36;95%置信区间:1.32,4.20;p=0.003)与运动伪影独立相关。运动伪影显著降低了出血检测的准确性。人工智能工具的这种降低幅度更大(从88%降至67%;p<0.001),而放射学报告的降低幅度较小(从100%降至93%;p<0.001)。缺血性和占位性病变的检测未受到显著影响。
运动伪影在疑似中风患者中很常见,但尤其在老年人和有运动症状的患者中更为常见,这降低了人工智能和放射科医生检测出血的准确性。
问题:运动伪影会降低MRI扫描质量,但尚不清楚哪些因素与之相关以及它们如何影响诊断准确性。发现:7%的疑似中风MRI扫描存在运动伪影,与患者年龄较大和运动症状有关,降低了人工智能和放射科医生对出血的检测能力。临床意义:中风脑部MRI中的运动伪影显著降低了人类和人工智能检测颅内出血的诊断准确性。老年患者和有运动症状的患者可能会从更注重运动伪影的预防和减少中受益。