Park Robert M
National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Cincinnati, OH 45230, USA.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2025 Jul 18;22(7):1145. doi: 10.3390/ijerph22071145.
To confirm a conjecture from year 2020 of the SARS-CoV-2 (COVID-19) pandemic suggesting policy alternatives to substantially reduce mortality burden.
Data from a global COVID-19 database comparing different countries on cumulative mortality and vaccination were analyzed in conjunction with surveys of seropositivity. Predictions of final mortality burden under an alternate policy scenario for Japan were calculated and the COVID-19 outcomes for China were assessed.
By 2025, Western countries (US, UK, Brazil and Italy) had cumulative mortality rates in the range of 3339-3548 deaths per million, about 6-fold higher than East Asian and New Zealand 'zero-COVID' countries. Moderate virus suppression in Japan produced the lowest cumulative mortality of the countries analyzed; if earlier policies had been maintained, the predicted cumulative mortality rate by 2025 would be one-tenth that of the US, UK, Brazil and Italy and one-half to one-third that of other zero-COVID countries. For China, transitioning from a zero-COVID policy in 2022-2023, the estimated 2025 cumulative mortality was 1607/million, half that of Western countries.
To minimize COVID-19 mortality would require: (1) Innovation on systematic sampling of ambient airborne virus exposure to sustain low but non-zero virus levels across entire populations, and (2) seropositivity assessment (instead of mass PCR testing for new cases) for calibrating exposure management, and tracking and protecting high-risk populations.
证实2020年新冠疫情期间的一个猜想,该猜想提出了大幅减轻死亡负担的政策选择。
结合血清阳性调查,分析了一个全球新冠数据库中不同国家在累计死亡率和疫苗接种方面的数据。计算了日本在另一种政策情景下的最终死亡负担预测,并评估了中国的新冠疫情结果。
到2025年,西方国家(美国、英国、巴西和意大利)的累计死亡率在每百万3339 - 3548例死亡之间,约为东亚和新西兰“动态清零”国家的6倍。日本适度的病毒抑制措施使其在分析的国家中累计死亡率最低;如果维持早期政策,到2025年预测的累计死亡率将是美国、英国、巴西和意大利的十分之一,是其他“动态清零”国家的二分之一到三分之一。对于中国,在2022 - 2023年从“动态清零”政策转变后,预计2025年的累计死亡率为每百万1607例,是西方国家的一半。
为使新冠死亡人数降至最低,需要:(1)创新对环境空气传播病毒暴露的系统采样,以在整个人口中维持低但非零的病毒水平,以及(2)进行血清阳性评估(而非对新病例进行大规模核酸检测)以校准暴露管理,并跟踪和保护高危人群。