Kampman Onno P, Ziminski Joe, Afyouni Soroosh, van der Wilk Mark, Kourtzi Zoe
Department of Psychology, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, United Kingdom.
Sainsbury Wellcome Centre for Neural Circuits and Behaviour, University College London, London, United Kingdom.
Imaging Neurosci (Camb). 2024 Jun 5;2. doi: 10.1162/imag_a_00184. eCollection 2024.
We investigate the utility of Wishart processes (WPs) for estimating time-varying functional connectivity (TVFC), which is a measure of changes in functional coupling as the correlation between brain region activity in functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI). The WP is a stochastic process on covariance matrices that can model dynamic covariances between time series, which makes it a natural fit to this task. Recent advances in scalable approximate inference techniques and the availability of robust open-source libraries have rendered the WP practically viable for fMRI applications. We introduce a comprehensive benchmarking framework to assess WP performance compared with a selection of established TVFC estimation methods. The framework comprises simulations with specified ground-truth covariance structures, a subject phenotype prediction task, a test-retest study, a brain state analysis, an external stimulus prediction task, and a novel data-driven imputation benchmark. The WP performed competitively across all the benchmarks. It outperformed a sliding window (SW) approach with adaptive cross-validated window lengths and a dynamic conditional correlation (DCC)-multivariate generalized autoregressive conditional heteroskedasticity (MGARCH) baseline on the external stimulus prediction task, while being less prone to false positives in the TVFC null models.
我们研究威沙特过程(WPs)在估计时变功能连接性(TVFC)方面的效用,TVFC是一种衡量功能耦合变化的指标,通过功能磁共振成像(fMRI)中脑区活动之间的相关性来体现。威沙特过程是协方差矩阵上的一种随机过程,能够对时间序列之间的动态协方差进行建模,这使其非常适合这项任务。可扩展近似推理技术的最新进展以及强大的开源库的可用性,使得威沙特过程在fMRI应用中切实可行。我们引入了一个全面的基准测试框架,以评估威沙特过程与一系列既定的TVFC估计方法相比的性能。该框架包括具有指定真实协方差结构的模拟、一个受试者表型预测任务、一项重测研究、一次脑状态分析、一个外部刺激预测任务以及一个全新的数据驱动插补基准测试。威沙特过程在所有基准测试中表现出色。在外部刺激预测任务中,它优于具有自适应交叉验证窗口长度的滑动窗口(SW)方法和动态条件相关(DCC)-多元广义自回归条件异方差(MGARCH)基线,同时在TVFC零模型中更不易出现假阳性。