Hill Ryan M, Schofield Holly, Boto Elena, Rier Lukas, Osborne James, Doyle Cody, Worcester Frank, Hayward Tyler, Holmes Niall, Bowtell Richard, Shah Vishal, Brookes Matthew J
Sir Peter Mansfield Imaging Centre, School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Nottingham, University Park, Nottingham, United Kingdom.
Cerca Magnetics Limited, Nottingham, United Kingdom.
Imaging Neurosci (Camb). 2024 Mar 19;2. doi: 10.1162/imag_a_00112. eCollection 2024.
The measurement of electrophysiology is of critical importance to our understanding of brain function. However, current non-invasive measurements-electroencephalography (EEG) and magnetoencephalography (MEG)-have limited sensitivity, particularly compared to invasive recordings. Optically-Pumped Magnetometers (OPMs) are a new type of magnetic field sensor which ostensibly promise MEG systems with higher sensitivity; however, the noise floor of current OPMs remains high compared to cryogenic instrumentation and this limits the achievable signal-to-noise ratio of OPM-MEG recordings. Here, we investigate how sensor array design affects sensitivity, and whether judicious sensor placement could compensate for the higher noise floor. Through theoretical analyses, simulations, and experiments, we use a beamformer framework to show that increasing the total signal measured by an OPM array-either by increasing the number of sensors and channels, or by optimising the placement of those sensors-affords a linearly proportional increase in signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) following beamformer reconstruction. Our experimental measurements confirm this finding, showing that by changing sensor locations in a 90-channel array, we could increase the SNR of visual gamma oscillations from 4.8 to 10.5. Using a 180-channel optimised OPM-array, we capture broadband gamma oscillations induced by a naturalistic visual paradigm, with an SNR of 3; a value that compares favourably to similar measures made using conventional MEG. Our findings show how an OPM-MEG array can be optimised to measure brain electrophysiology with the highest possible sensitivity. This is important for the design of future OPM-based instrumentation.
电生理测量对于我们理解脑功能至关重要。然而,当前的非侵入性测量方法——脑电图(EEG)和脑磁图(MEG)——灵敏度有限,尤其是与侵入性记录相比。光泵磁力仪(OPM)是一种新型磁场传感器,表面上有望为MEG系统提供更高的灵敏度;然而,与低温仪器相比,当前OPM的本底噪声仍然很高,这限制了OPM-MEG记录可实现的信噪比。在此,我们研究传感器阵列设计如何影响灵敏度,以及明智的传感器放置是否可以弥补更高的本底噪声。通过理论分析、模拟和实验,我们使用波束形成器框架表明,增加OPM阵列测量的总信号——要么通过增加传感器和通道的数量,要么通过优化这些传感器的放置——在波束形成器重建后可使信噪比(SNR)呈线性比例增加。我们的实验测量证实了这一发现,表明通过改变90通道阵列中的传感器位置,我们可以将视觉伽马振荡的SNR从4.8提高到10.5。使用180通道优化的OPM阵列,我们捕获了由自然视觉范式诱发的宽带伽马振荡,SNR为3;该值与使用传统MEG进行的类似测量结果相比具有优势。我们的研究结果表明了如何优化OPM-MEG阵列以尽可能高的灵敏度测量脑电生理。这对于未来基于OPM的仪器设计很重要。