Walker Mary Jean
La Trobe University, Bundoora, Melbourne VIC 3086, Australia.
J Bioeth Inq. 2025 Aug 13. doi: 10.1007/s11673-025-10443-6.
Alcohol use causes significant harms and is extensively regulated by governments, but alcohol-related questions are under-explored in public health ethics. To inform future work in this area, I conducted interviews with key informants from alcohol research and policy work in Australia. Thematic analysis of interviews identified a range of ethical issues that can be categorized under six themes: ethical issues in alcohol research; ethical issues raised by judgements about alcohol use; ethical issues raised by alcohol policies; ethical issues in policy processes; ethical questions about policy aims; and ethical issues in how alcohol problems are defined. The study provides direction for future research on problems that are underexplored in the ethics literature. These include problems arising from the influence of industry in alcohol research and policy, the question of how to develop research and policy without generating stigma, and social justice issues connected to alcohol-related stereotypes and judgements.
饮酒会造成重大危害,并且受到政府的广泛监管,但与酒精相关的问题在公共卫生伦理学中却未得到充分探讨。为了给该领域未来的工作提供信息,我采访了澳大利亚酒精研究和政策工作的关键信息提供者。对访谈进行的主题分析确定了一系列伦理问题,这些问题可分为六个主题:酒精研究中的伦理问题;关于饮酒判断所引发的伦理问题;酒精政策所引发的伦理问题;政策制定过程中的伦理问题;关于政策目标的伦理问题;以及酒精问题定义方式中的伦理问题。该研究为伦理学文献中未充分探讨的问题的未来研究提供了方向。这些问题包括酒精研究和政策中行业影响所产生的问题、如何在不产生污名化的情况下开展研究和制定政策的问题,以及与酒精相关的刻板印象和判断有关的社会正义问题。