Porter Hat
, Exeter, UK.
J Eat Disord. 2025 Aug 15;13(1):177. doi: 10.1186/s40337-025-01266-2.
Although no longer specified within the diagnostic criteria for anorexia nervosa, the prevalence of menstrual disturbances among patients with eating disorders is well-documented. However, there is limited research examining patient experiences of amenorrhoea and eating disorders, or addressing how the topic is approached by eating disorder services. This article presents a subgroup analysis of a survivor-led qualitative study, which examined experiences of menstrual health in psychiatric inpatient settings. The study's main findings remain relevant to eating disorder services, however, this article presents an additional subgroup analysis which identified two themes from participants with experience of inpatient eating disorder services.
Thematic analysis was used to analyse qualitative data generated through questionnaires with staff and people with lived experience of inpatient settings and interviews with people with lived experience. An additional subgroup analysis was conducted to further explore the experiences which were specific to the eating disorder context.
Three interviewees, 13 lived experience and two staff questionnaire respondents had experience related to eating disorder services. Eating disorder services were reported to place significant emphasis on the menstrual cycle as a marker of health, informing patient meal plans and weight targets. However, the emotional impact of managing the return of menstruation, and its significance within the context of their eating disorder, was not adequately addressed. Invasive practices of forcing patients to display used menstrual products to staff, as evidence of their menstruation, were reported.
The menstrual cycle is an important consideration in the treatment of patients with eating disorders, however, this should extend beyond monitoring the presence or absence of menstrual cycles to consider a more holistic perspective of menstrual health. This should include provision of information; how menstrual and gynaecological conditions may interact with someone's eating disorder; and addressing psychological and emotional needs related to menstruation in eating disorder treatment and recovery. Further research is needed to understand these experiences in greater depth.
尽管神经性厌食症的诊断标准中不再明确提及,但饮食失调患者月经紊乱的患病率已有充分记录。然而,关于闭经与饮食失调患者经历的研究有限,或者关于饮食失调服务机构如何处理该话题的研究也很有限。本文呈现了一项由幸存者主导的定性研究的亚组分析,该研究考察了精神科住院环境中的月经健康经历。该研究的主要发现对饮食失调服务机构仍具有相关性,不过,本文呈现了一项额外的亚组分析,该分析从有住院饮食失调服务经历的参与者中识别出了两个主题。
采用主题分析法分析通过对工作人员和有住院经历的人进行问卷调查以及对有住院经历的人进行访谈所产生的定性数据。进行了一项额外的亚组分析,以进一步探究饮食失调背景下的特定经历。
三名受访者、13名有住院经历者以及两名工作人员问卷受访者有与饮食失调服务相关的经历。据报告,饮食失调服务机构非常强调月经周期作为健康指标的作用,以此来制定患者的饮食计划和体重目标。然而,月经恢复的管理所带来的情感影响及其在饮食失调背景下的重要性并未得到充分关注。有报告称存在强迫患者向工作人员展示用过的月经用品以证明其月经情况的侵入性做法。
月经周期是饮食失调患者治疗中的一个重要考量因素,然而,这应该超越对月经周期是否存在的监测,而要从更全面的角度考虑月经健康。这应包括提供信息;月经和妇科状况如何与某人的饮食失调相互作用;以及在饮食失调治疗和康复过程中满足与月经相关的心理和情感需求。需要进一步研究以更深入地了解这些经历。