Ahmady Soleiman, Kalantarion Masomeh, Shahbazi Sara, Bagheri Sara, Sohrabi Somaye, Babaei Samane, Allahgholipour Amirreza, Barary Mohammad, Hosseinzadeh Rezvan
Department of Medical Education, School of Medical Education and Learning Technologies, Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran.
Department of Medical Education, Vice of Center for Recruitment and Affairs of Academic Members and Elites, Shahrekord University of Medical Sciences, Shahrekord, Iran.
J Educ Health Promot. 2025 Jul 31;14:274. doi: 10.4103/jehp.jehp_219_24. eCollection 2025.
In Iran, efforts have been made to integrate medical education and the health system with the aim of promoting social responsiveness. Despite these efforts, there is still room for improvement in this process. To gain a better understanding of this topic, a study was carried out to gather insights from experts on the integration of medical education in the Iranian health system.
This qualitative study utilized Norman Fairclough's discourse analysis. Data collection involved interviews and video reports. The data collection took place in Tehran between November 2022 and February 2023. The participants included 10 policymakers and key informants who possessed in-depth knowledge about the integration of medical education into the health system. Additionally, six related speeches from media were subjected to qualitative inductive content analysis.
Through discourse analysis, 96 codes, 17 categories, and 8 themes were extracted. The themes include the philosophy and objectives of integration, the concept of integration, the experience of the integration process, achievements of integration, future horizon of integration, indicators of integration, strategies for enhancing integration, and challenges and consequences of abstracting medical education from the healthcare system.
Despite facing challenges and limitations, integration has managed to achieve some of its original objectives. However, these achievements have been hindered by inadequate implementation, managerial shortcomings, and pre-existing cultural and economic issues within both the educational and service systems. Therefore, it is essential for the country's educational and service systems to take charge of integration, complete the process, and strive for functional integration. This requires health policy to prioritize integration efforts, address systemic barriers, engage stakeholders, and ensure that integration initiatives are guided by expert opinions and best practices. By doing so, policymakers can create a healthcare system that is more responsive to the needs of patients, more efficient in delivering care, and more effective in educating the next generation of healthcare professionals.
在伊朗,已努力将医学教育与卫生系统相结合,以提高社会响应能力。尽管做出了这些努力,但在此过程中仍有改进空间。为了更好地理解这一主题,开展了一项研究,以收集专家对伊朗卫生系统中医学教育整合的见解。
这项定性研究采用了诺曼·费尔克拉夫的话语分析方法。数据收集包括访谈和视频报告。数据收集于2022年11月至2023年2月在德黑兰进行。参与者包括10名政策制定者和关键信息提供者,他们对医学教育融入卫生系统拥有深入了解。此外,对媒体的六篇相关演讲进行了定性归纳内容分析。
通过话语分析,提取了96个代码、17个类别和8个主题。这些主题包括整合的理念和目标、整合的概念、整合过程的经验、整合的成就、整合的未来前景、整合的指标、加强整合的策略以及将医学教育从医疗系统中抽象出来的挑战和后果。
尽管面临挑战和限制,但整合已设法实现了其一些最初目标。然而,这些成就受到实施不足、管理缺陷以及教育和服务系统中既有的文化和经济问题的阻碍。因此,该国的教育和服务系统必须负责整合,完成这一过程,并努力实现功能整合。这需要卫生政策将整合努力列为优先事项,消除系统性障碍,让利益相关者参与进来,并确保整合举措以专家意见和最佳实践为指导。通过这样做,政策制定者可以创建一个更能响应患者需求、提供护理更高效、教育下一代医疗专业人员更有效的医疗系统。