Qudaih Mohanad S A, Abu Daqqa Hamza A, AlNajjar Omar R, Wehedi Dalia T A, Khoury Rasha, Bouquet Benjamin, Matos Lisa, Sariahmed Karim
Faculty of Medicine, Al-Quds University, Jerusalem, Palestine.
Faculty of Medicine, Islamic University, Gaza, Palestine.
PLOS Glob Public Health. 2025 Sep 10;5(9):e0005094. doi: 10.1371/journal.pgph.0005094. eCollection 2025.
On January 26th 2024, the International Court of Justice (ICJ) recognized plausible grounds for genocide being committed in Gaza by Israel. A hallmark of the violence has been unprecedented attacks on health workers since October 7th, 2023. We use the word "genocide" to refer to this period of accelerated violence and displacement in Gaza, following ICJ findings, detailed reports by human rights organizations, and statements by genocide scholars concluding that Israel is indeed committing genocide. To assess impacts of this violence, between December 2023 and January 2024 we conducted an anonymous cross-sectional online survey of physicians and nurses working in Gaza prior to and during the genocide. Participants reported on workplace displacement, personal losses, and psychological impacts using the Professional Quality of Life Scale for Health Workers (ProQOL-H). 56 participants completed one or more survey components. Among 46 participants reporting on displacement, 25 (54%) reported having to change workplaces at least once. Among 41 participants documenting personal loss, 17 (41%) reported that a family member was killed and 32 (78%) reported that a close colleague was killed. Among 35 participants completing the ProQOL-H, 17 (49%) respondents reported "high" compassion satisfaction (scores of 24-30), 13 (37%) reported high burnout, and 13 (37%) reported high secondary traumatic stress. This is markedly different from CS, BO, and STS scores reported by nurses in the West Bank in a recent study, likely reflecting the genocide in Gaza. Further work with survivors is needed to characterize their experiences and reconcile them with culture-specific coping strategies such as sumud. Culturally relevant, mixed methods follow up to this work is needed to inform interventions to support the recovery of survivors and rebuild Gaza's healthcare system. This will only be possible when the genocide is brought to a permanent end, along with the conditions which have enabled it.
2024年1月26日,国际法院(ICJ)确认有合理理由认定以色列在加沙地带实施种族灭绝。自2023年10月7日以来,暴力行为的一个显著特征是对医护人员前所未有的袭击。根据国际法院的调查结果、人权组织的详细报告以及种族灭绝问题学者的声明,这些声明得出以色列确实在实施种族灭绝的结论,我们使用“种族灭绝”一词来指代加沙地带这段暴力加速和人口流离失所的时期。为评估这场暴力的影响,在2023年12月至2024年1月期间,我们对在种族灭绝发生之前及期间在加沙地带工作的医生和护士进行了一项匿名横断面在线调查。参与者使用医护人员职业生活质量量表(ProQOL-H)报告了工作场所的变动、个人损失和心理影响。56名参与者完成了一个或多个调查部分。在46名报告工作场所变动的参与者中,25人(54%)报告至少更换过一次工作场所。在41名记录个人损失的参与者中,17人(41%)报告有家庭成员丧生,32人(78%)报告有亲密同事丧生。在35名完成ProQOL-H量表的参与者中,17名(49%)受访者报告“高度”同情满足感(得分24 - 30),13名(37%)报告有高度职业倦怠,13名(37%)报告有高度继发性创伤压力。这与最近一项研究中约旦河西岸护士报告的同情满足感、职业倦怠和继发性创伤压力得分明显不同,这可能反映了加沙地带的种族灭绝情况。需要进一步与幸存者合作,以了解他们的经历,并使这些经历与诸如“sumud”等特定文化的应对策略相协调。需要开展与文化相关的混合方法后续研究,为支持幸存者康复和重建加沙医疗系统的干预措施提供信息。只有当种族灭绝永久结束以及使其得以发生的条件消除时,这才有可能实现。