Platto Sara, Normando Simona, Serres Agathe, Manteca Xavier, Temple Deborah
Department of Biotechnology, College of Life Sciences, Jianghan University, Wuhan, China.
Department of Comparative Biomedicine and Food Sciences, Padova University, Padova, Italy.
Front Vet Sci. 2025 Aug 25;12:1627981. doi: 10.3389/fvets.2025.1627981. eCollection 2025.
The One Welfare framework emphasizes the interconnection between animal, human, and environmental well-being, extending One Health principles to address broader welfare dimensions. Despite its relevance, One Welfare remains underexplored. This study investigates global research trends and thematic priorities in One Welfare literature published from 2013 to 2024. A bibliometric review was conducted using PubMed, Elsevier, Springer, Web of Science, Scopus, and CABI databases. A literature search was conducted using keywords translated into five of the world's most widely spoken languages: Hindi, Chinese, Spanish, English, and French. A total of 111 publications were identified and categorized into four main domains-Policy, Governance, Economy (PGE); Applied Human-Animal Sciences (AHAS); Societal, Economic, Environmental Dimensions (SEED); and Human-Animal Bond and Mental Health (HAB-MH)-and eight subcategories: Legal Framework and Economy (LFE); Education and Philosophy (EP); Sustainable Resource Management (SRM); Traditional Knowledge and Societal Impact (TKSI); Animal Management (AM); Human-Animal Diseases (HAD); Human-Animal Interaction (HAI); and Psychology (PSY). The analysis also considered animal types-companion animals (CA), production animals (PA), wild animals (WA), working/sport animals (WS), and general (GE)-and divided data into two time periods (2013-2018, 2019-2024). Most publications (78) emerged after 2018, with Animal Management (AM) subcategory as the dominant theme, particularly in relation to PA reflecting their significance in food security. Human-Animal Interaction (HAI) was the second most represented theme among the subcategories, particularly in relation to CA underlining their significance in human lives. Conversely, wild animals (WA), climate change, and working/sport animals (WS) remain underrepresented. Education and Philosophy was the least addressed subcategory, exposing a critical gap in integrating One Welfare into veterinary and animal science education. Given the limited number of publications identified over the past 11 years, there is a clear need to promote increased interdisciplinary research, policy development, and educational reform to fully implement the One Welfare framework and align it with global sustainability goals.
“同一福利”框架强调动物、人类和环境福祉之间的相互联系,将“同一健康”原则扩展到更广泛的福利层面。尽管其具有相关性,但“同一福利”仍未得到充分探索。本研究调查了2013年至2024年发表的“同一福利”文献中的全球研究趋势和主题重点。使用PubMed、爱思唯尔、施普林格、科学网、Scopus和CABI数据库进行了文献计量学综述。使用翻译成世界上使用最广泛的五种语言(印地语、中文、西班牙语、英语和法语)的关键词进行了文献检索。共识别出111篇出版物,并将其分为四个主要领域——政策、治理、经济(PGE);应用人类与动物科学(AHAS);社会、经济、环境维度(SEED);以及人类与动物关系及心理健康(HAB-MH)——和八个子类别:法律框架与经济(LFE);教育与哲学(EP);可持续资源管理(SRM);传统知识与社会影响(TKSI);动物管理(AM);人类与动物疾病(HAD);人类与动物互动(HAI);以及心理学(PSY)。分析还考虑了动物类型——伴侣动物(CA)、生产动物(PA)、野生动物(WA)、工作/运动动物(WS)和一般动物(GE)——并将数据分为两个时间段(2013 - 2018年,2019 - 2024年)。大多数出版物(78篇)出现在2018年之后,动物管理(AM)子类别是主导主题,特别是与生产动物相关,这反映了它们在粮食安全中的重要性。人类与动物互动(HAI)是子类别中第二大突出主题,特别是与伴侣动物相关,突出了它们在人类生活中的重要性。相反,野生动物(WA)、气候变化和工作/运动动物(WS)的代表性仍然不足。教育与哲学是涉及最少的子类别,这暴露了将“同一福利”纳入兽医和动物科学教育方面的关键差距。鉴于在过去11年中识别出的出版物数量有限,显然需要促进更多的跨学科研究、政策制定和教育改革,以全面实施“同一福利”框架并使其与全球可持续发展目标保持一致。