Cole K S, Guttman R, Bezanilla F
Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 1970 Apr;65(4):884-91. doi: 10.1073/pnas.65.4.884.
Evidence is presented to show that for a squid axon membrane the potential response, V, is a smoothly continuous function of a stimulating current, I. This makes it unlikely that an all-or-none or sharp transition phenomenon is a major factor in the processes by which ions cross the normal squid axon membrane and, probably, other excitable membranes. Spatially uniform V and I were first produced in the squid axon with internal and external electrode arrangements and later by isolating a short length of axon between external pools of sucrose. Under these simplified conditions, direct experiments and calculations based on the Hodgkin-Huxley empirical conductances agree in showing that the maximum response, R, is a continuous, single-valued function of the effect of the stimulus, S. The maximum value of DeltaR/DeltaS decreased steadily as the temperatures were increased from 25 degrees to 38 degrees C. Uncontrolled fluctuations prevented direct observations of DeltaR/DeltaS below 15 degrees C where calculations showed that it rose rapidly as the temperature decreased. Since the conductances are experimental parameters and since DeltaR/DeltaS as calculated from them remained finite and continuous event at 6.3 degrees C, this is experimental evidence against an all-or-none threshold excitation. However there is an all-or-none threshold for the initiation and propagation of an impulse along an axon where V and I are functions of both time and distance.
有证据表明,对于鱿鱼轴突膜,电位响应V是刺激电流I的平滑连续函数。这使得全或无或急剧转变现象不太可能是离子穿过正常鱿鱼轴突膜以及可能其他可兴奋膜的过程中的主要因素。最初通过内部和外部电极布置在鱿鱼轴突中产生空间均匀的V和I,后来通过在外部蔗糖池中隔离一小段轴突来实现。在这些简化条件下,基于霍奇金 - 赫胥黎经验电导的直接实验和计算一致表明,最大响应R是刺激效应S的连续单值函数。随着温度从25℃升高到38℃,ΔR/ΔS的最大值稳步下降。在15℃以下,不受控制的波动妨碍了对ΔR/ΔS的直接观测,而计算表明,随着温度降低,它会迅速上升。由于电导是实验参数,并且从它们计算出的ΔR/ΔS在6.3℃时仍保持有限且连续,这是反对全或无阈值激发的实验证据。然而,沿着轴突的冲动的起始和传播存在全或无阈值,其中V和I是时间和距离的函数。