Haile R W, Hodge S E, Iselius L
Int J Epidemiol. 1983 Mar;12(1):8-16. doi: 10.1093/ije/12.1.8.
We review evidence on genetic susceptibility to multiple sclerosis provided by studies of family resemblance, migrants, twins, HLA-associations, and segregation and linkage analyses. The higher concordance rate in MZ than DZ twins and the increasing prevalence with increasing degree of kinship to propositi suggest that genetic factors are involved in the aetiology of MS. Nonetheless, the low overall twin concordance rates, the increased prevalence of MS in DZ twins over siblings, and the weight of evidence from migrant studies strongly suggest the involvement of environmental factors as well. These results can be reconciled by hypothesizing an MS susceptibility gene with reduced penetrance, where full phenotypic expression depends on critical environmental exposures. The location of this gene in or near the HLA region is suggested by the reports of HLA-MS associations and is supported by results of formal linkage analyses. Two general hypotheses have emerged. One involves loose linkage with no heterogeneity while the other involves very tight linkage and substantial heterogeneity, ie no linkage in 25% of the pedigrees. Since the MS gene is probably not a recent mutation, the hypothesis of loose linkage requires one to postulate intense selection to maintain linkage disequilibrium. It is primarily because of this intense selection that we currently favour the hypothesis of tight linkage with heterogeneity over any single-gene hypothesis involving loose linkage, given our present biological knowledge. Areas for future research are suggested.
我们回顾了通过家族相似性、移民、双胞胎、HLA关联以及分离和连锁分析等研究提供的关于多发性硬化症遗传易感性的证据。同卵双胞胎(MZ)的一致性率高于异卵双胞胎(DZ),并且与先证者的亲缘关系程度越高患病率越高,这表明遗传因素参与了MS的病因。尽管如此,总体双胞胎一致性率较低、DZ双胞胎中MS的患病率高于兄弟姐妹,以及移民研究的大量证据都强烈表明环境因素也参与其中。通过假设一个外显率降低的MS易感基因可以调和这些结果,其中完整的表型表达取决于关键的环境暴露。HLA与MS关联的报告表明该基因位于HLA区域内或附近,正式连锁分析的结果也支持这一点。出现了两个普遍的假设。一个涉及无基因异质性的松散连锁,而另一个涉及非常紧密的连锁和大量的基因异质性,即在25%的家系中无连锁。由于MS基因可能不是近期的突变,松散连锁的假设要求人们假定有强烈的选择来维持连锁不平衡。主要是因为这种强烈的选择,鉴于我们目前的生物学知识,相较于任何涉及松散连锁的单基因假设,我们目前更倾向于紧密连锁与基因异质性的假设。文中还提出了未来的研究方向。