Todd J K, Todd N, Damato J, Todd W A
Pediatr Infect Dis. 1984 May-Jun;3(3):226-32. doi: 10.1097/00006454-198405000-00009.
One hundred forty-two children with purulent nasopharyngitis were randomized to four treatment groups with an antibiotic (cephalexin) alone or combined with a decongestant/antihistamine (pseudoephedrine/triprolidine) or their corresponding placebo equivalents. Follow-up evaluations by parents and physicians and bacteriologic evaluations were performed after 5 to 6 days of therapy. Groups were comparable with regard to age, sex, race, number of patients withdrawn from the study, fever greater than 38.0 degrees C, appearance of nasal discharge, nasal crusting and number of days until follow-up. Initial cultures from patients grew: Streptococcus pneumoniae, 46%; Haemophilus influenzae type b, 21%; and Streptococcus pyogenes, 8%. Nasal crusting was significantly associated with the growth of S. pneumoniae or H. influenzae type b. There were no significant differences between active drug and placebo treatment groups for change in nasal discharge, complications or apparent drug benefit. Cephalexin therapy did not result in a decrease in cultivation of pathogenic organisms from the nasopharynx. Significantly more side effects were attributed to pseudoephedrine/triprolidine treatment than to placebo. Routine culture or treatment of purulent nasopharyngitis should not be considered unless future controlled clinical trials demonstrate some therapeutic benefit.
142名患有化脓性鼻咽炎的儿童被随机分为四个治疗组,分别单独使用抗生素(头孢氨苄)或与减充血剂/抗组胺药(伪麻黄碱/曲普利啶)联合使用,或使用相应的安慰剂等效物。治疗5至6天后,由家长和医生进行随访评估,并进行细菌学评估。各组在年龄、性别、种族、退出研究的患者数量、体温高于38.0摄氏度、出现鼻涕、鼻结痂以及随访前天数等方面具有可比性。患者的初始培养结果显示:肺炎链球菌占46%;b型流感嗜血杆菌占21%;化脓性链球菌占8%。鼻结痂与肺炎链球菌或b型流感嗜血杆菌的生长显著相关。在鼻涕变化、并发症或明显的药物疗效方面,活性药物治疗组与安慰剂治疗组之间没有显著差异。头孢氨苄治疗并未导致鼻咽部致病微生物培养数量减少。与安慰剂相比,伪麻黄碱/曲普利啶治疗导致的副作用明显更多。除非未来的对照临床试验证明有一定的治疗益处,否则不应考虑对化脓性鼻咽炎进行常规培养或治疗。