Swindell P J, Reeves D S, Bullock D W, Davies A J, Spence C E
Br Med J (Clin Res Ed). 1983 Jan 8;286(6359):118-22. doi: 10.1136/bmj.286.6359.118.
Audits of antibiotic prescribing were done for periods of up to eight weeks in two successive years on medical, surgical, orthopaedic, gynaecology, obstetric, and urology wards and in an accident and emergency department. Clinical details were matched with antibiotic prescribing, and the appropriateness of the latter was judged independently by two medical microbiologists. Only when they agreed was an individual prescription included in the analysis. Overall, 28% of prescriptions in 1979 and 35% in 1980 were judged as unnecessary, with 17% and 16%, respectively, being for inappropriate choices of antibiotic. An educational programme about antibiotic prescribing carried out between the audits had no beneficial effect overall. Though the results compared favourably with those of audits published, prescribing could still be much improved. To judge by the failure of education, however, this might be difficult to achieve. Most prescriptions were written by junior staff, who in the absence of guidance from their seniors and because of their frequent moves would require a widespread and continual education programme. Published concern about the quality of antibiotic prescribing appears to be justified.
在连续两年里,对内科、外科、骨科、妇科、产科、泌尿科病房以及急诊科进行了为期长达八周的抗生素处方审核。临床细节与抗生素处方相匹配,后者的合理性由两名医学微生物学家独立判断。只有在他们意见一致时,个体处方才会纳入分析。总体而言,1979年28%的处方以及1980年35%的处方被判定为不必要,分别有17%和16%是因为抗生素选择不当。在两次审核之间开展的关于抗生素处方的教育项目总体上没有产生有益效果。尽管结果与已发表的审核结果相比不错,但处方仍有很大改进空间。然而,从教育的失败来看,这可能难以实现。大多数处方是由初级医护人员开具的,由于缺乏上级指导且他们频繁轮岗,这就需要一个广泛且持续的教育项目。已发表的关于抗生素处方质量的担忧似乎是合理的。