Bergenholtz A, Gustafsson L B, Segerlund N, Hagberg C, Ostby N
Scand J Dent Res. 1984 Aug;92(4):344-51. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-0722.1984.tb00901.x.
Twenty-four adults participated in an intraindividual crossover experimental study to compare the plaque removing ability of straight multitufted and V-shaped brushes. Twelve of the participants had loss of periodontal tissue resulting in open but healthy interdental areas while the other 12 displayed no periodontal breakdown. In part 1 the participants were asked to brush their teeth using their own brushing technique and length over two 12-day periods during which time they, at random, used one brush for the first and the other brush for the second period. In part 2 the participants were professionally brushed by two dental assistants using four brushing techniques (The Bass, The Roll, The Circular Scrub and The Horizontal Scrub) randomly assigned to the four quadrants of the mouth. Cleaning was performed once a day for two 5-day periods, during which time the participants refrained from brushing and interdental cleaning. Initial toothbrush assignment was randomized. At the beginning of the study and each test period no plaque or gingival inflammation was visible. At the end of each period the accumulated plaque was registered. The results showed that there was no difference between the two brushes tested in the unsupervised part. The plaque removing ability when using either of the brushes varied between participants. When professionally used the straight multitufted and V-shaped toothbrushes did not show any difference in plaque removal on buccal and lingual surfaces. Interproximally the V-shaped toothbrush was better at plaque removal than the straight one.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
24名成年人参与了一项个体内交叉实验研究,以比较直多束刷毛牙刷和V形刷毛牙刷的牙菌斑清除能力。其中12名参与者存在牙周组织丧失,导致牙间隙开放但健康,而另外12名参与者未出现牙周组织破坏。在第一部分,参与者被要求在两个为期12天的时间段内,按照自己的刷牙方法和刷牙时长刷牙,在此期间,他们随机在第一个时间段使用一种牙刷,在第二个时间段使用另一种牙刷。在第二部分,两名牙科助手使用四种刷牙方法(巴氏刷牙法、旋转刷牙法、画圈擦洗法和水平擦洗法)为参与者进行专业刷牙,这些方法被随机分配到口腔的四个象限。每天清洁一次,为期两个5天的时间段,在此期间参与者不进行刷牙和牙间隙清洁。最初的牙刷分配是随机的。在研究开始时和每个测试阶段,均未观察到牙菌斑或牙龈炎症。在每个阶段结束时,记录累积的牙菌斑。结果表明,在无监督的部分,测试的两种牙刷之间没有差异。使用任何一种牙刷时,参与者之间的牙菌斑清除能力各不相同。在专业刷牙时,直多束刷毛牙刷和V形刷毛牙刷在颊面和舌面的牙菌斑清除方面没有显示出任何差异。在牙间隙处,V形刷毛牙刷比直多束刷毛牙刷在清除牙菌斑方面表现更好。(摘要截选至250词)