Beck-Peccoz P, Romelli P B, Faglia G
J Endocrinol Invest. 1983 Oct;6(5):333-40. doi: 10.1007/BF03347612.
Two clinically euthyroid patients were noted to have low total T3 levels as assessed by RIA using either dextran-charcoal (DC) or polyethylene glycol (PEG) for separation of bound from unbound T3, in spite of normal free T3, total and free T4 and basal and TRH-stimulated TSH concentrations. The presence of circulating substances binding T3 was suggested by high nonspecific binding in total T3 RIA system using either DC or PEG separation. The presence of anti-T3 autoantibodies was then suspected and confirmed by the presence of [125]-T3 bound to patients' gammaglobulins, precipitated with rabbit anti-human immunoglobulins. Serum T3 concentration determined by extracting T3 from patients' sera with methanol was 166 and 226 ng/dl. Similar or even lower values were unexpectedly obtained in RIA systems with solid phase or second antibody (anti-rabbit) separation and with competitive protein binding assay. To face this paradoxical finding, simulated experiments were carried out by incubating T3- and T4-free sera added with various amounts of stable T3 and T4 in the presence of goat anti-T3 or anti-T4 serum. These samples were then radioimmunoassayed. The DC separation caused a consistent underestimation of the actual T3 and T4 concentration. The second antibody separation caused a T3 and T4 overestimation for actual levels below 200 ng/dl and 10 micrograms/dl, respectively, while at the higher T3 or T4 concentrations, an overlap or, even, an underestimation of actual T3 or T4 levels were found. These data provide evidence that, with second antibody or solid phase separation methods, there could be an apparent lack of interfering effect of endogenously occurring antibodies.
两名临床甲状腺功能正常的患者,尽管其游离T3、总T4和游离T4以及基础和促甲状腺激素释放激素(TRH)刺激后的促甲状腺激素(TSH)浓度均正常,但通过使用葡聚糖-活性炭(DC)或聚乙二醇(PEG)分离结合型和游离型T3的放射免疫分析(RIA)评估,发现其总T3水平较低。在使用DC或PEG分离的总T3 RIA系统中,高非特异性结合提示存在循环中结合T3的物质。随后怀疑存在抗T3自身抗体,并通过与兔抗人免疫球蛋白沉淀后与患者γ球蛋白结合的[125] -T3的存在得到证实。用甲醇从患者血清中提取T3后测定的血清T3浓度分别为166和226 ng/dl。在采用固相或第二抗体(抗兔)分离的RIA系统以及竞争性蛋白结合分析中,意外获得了相似甚至更低的值。为了面对这一矛盾的发现,进行了模拟实验,在山羊抗T3或抗T4血清存在的情况下,将添加了不同量稳定T3和T4的无T3和T4血清进行孵育。然后对这些样品进行放射免疫分析。DC分离导致实际T3和T4浓度持续低估。第二抗体分离在实际水平分别低于200 ng/dl和10 μg/dl时导致T3和T4高估,而在较高的T3或T4浓度下,发现实际T3或T4水平出现重叠甚至低估。这些数据证明,使用第二抗体或固相分离方法时,内源性抗体可能明显缺乏干扰作用。