Turunen M J, Liewendahl K, Partanen P, Adlercreutz H
Br J Cancer. 1984 Feb;49(2):141-8. doi: 10.1038/bjc.1984.26.
A new two-phase test kit for faecal occult blood combining a sensitive guaiac test (Fecatwin (S)ensitive) with an immunological test for human haemoglobin (FECA-EIA) was compared with three current guaiac tests (Fecatest, Fecatwin, Haemoccult) in 19 colorectal cancer patients and 11 controls on a restricted diet. A total of 43 48 h faecal samples (30 from cancer patients and 13 from controls) were collected for quantitative determination of faecal blood loss with the 51Cr method. Qualitative testing revealed that FECA-EIA was the most sensitive test, giving one (3%) false negative test result in the 30 tests on colorectal cancer patients and no false positives in the control subjects. It was also the only test that detected low-degree tumour bleeding. Fecatest and Fecatwin S were the most sensitive guaiac tests, giving 7 and 10% false negative test results, respectively, in the 30 colorectal cancer samples, whereas Haemoccult and Fecatwin gave 23% false negative test results. For screening purposes and in order to reduce costs it is suggested that only the positive test results of the very sensitive guaiac test (Fecatwin S) should be tested with the FECA-EIA test to eliminate false positive results. With this approach the diagnostic accuracy of the new two-phase test will be about twice as good as for the Haemoccult test.
一种新型的粪便潜血两相检测试剂盒,将灵敏的愈创木脂检测法(Fecatwin(S)ensitive)与人类血红蛋白免疫检测法(FECA - EIA)相结合,与三种现行的愈创木脂检测法(Fecatest、Fecatwin、Haemoccult)在19例结直肠癌患者和11例饮食受限的对照者中进行了比较。共收集了43份48小时的粪便样本(30份来自癌症患者,13份来自对照者),采用51Cr法对粪便失血进行定量测定。定性检测显示,FECA - EIA是最灵敏的检测方法,在对结直肠癌患者进行的30次检测中给出了1次(3%)假阴性检测结果,在对照者中未出现假阳性结果。它也是唯一能检测到低度肿瘤出血的检测方法。Fecatest和Fecatwin S是最灵敏的愈创木脂检测法,在30份结直肠癌样本中分别给出了7%和10%的假阴性检测结果,而Haemoccult和Fecatwin给出了23%的假阴性检测结果。为了进行筛查并降低成本,建议仅用FECA - EIA检测法对非常灵敏的愈创木脂检测法(Fecatwin S)的阳性检测结果进行检测,以消除假阳性结果。采用这种方法,新型两相检测法的诊断准确性将是Haemoccult检测法的两倍左右。