Ellis M E, Sahay J N, Chatterjee S S, Cruickshank J M, Ellis S H
Eur J Clin Pharmacol. 1981;21(3):173-6. doi: 10.1007/BF00627916.
This double-blind, randomised, within patient, placebo-controlled study set out to investigate the effect of a cardioselective beta-blocker, atenolol, at different oral doses (50, 100 and 200 mg) and a non-selective agent, propranolol (40 mg), upon 1. airways resistance (forced expiratory volume at one second = FEV1) and 2. the bronchodilator action of increasing doses of inhaled isoprenaline, in patients with co-existent hypertension and reversible airways obstruction. In 10 patients, two hours after drug administration, the 3 doses of atenolol caused a significantly greater (P less than 0.05) degree of B1-blockade than propranolol. In contrast the 3 doses of atenolol caused significantly less (P less than 0.05 to 0.01) B2-blockade as evidenced by a smaller fall in FEV1. The isoprenaline FEV1 dose response curves were displaced progressively to the right of the placebo curve with increasing doses of atenolol, but the greatest displacement was with propranolol. It was concluded that patients with reversible airways obstruction who require beta-blockade should be given a low dose of a cardioselective agent in conjunction with, if required, a beta 2 stimulant such as isoprenaline. Such a treatment will be less likely to cause a troublesome increase in airways resistance and the bronchodilator action of the beta 2 stimulant will be almost fully preserved.
这项双盲、随机、患者自身对照、安慰剂对照研究旨在调查不同口服剂量(50、100和200毫克)的心脏选择性β受体阻滞剂阿替洛尔以及非选择性药物普萘洛尔(40毫克)对同时患有高血压和可逆性气道阻塞患者的以下影响:1. 气道阻力(一秒用力呼气量=FEV1);2. 递增剂量吸入异丙肾上腺素的支气管扩张作用。在10名患者中,给药两小时后,3种剂量的阿替洛尔引起的β1受体阻滞程度显著高于普萘洛尔(P<0.05)。相比之下,3种剂量的阿替洛尔引起的β2受体阻滞显著较少(P<0.05至0.01),FEV1下降幅度较小即证明了这一点。随着阿替洛尔剂量增加,异丙肾上腺素FEV1剂量反应曲线逐渐向安慰剂曲线右侧移动,但普萘洛尔引起的移动最大。得出的结论是,需要β受体阻滞的可逆性气道阻塞患者应给予低剂量的心脏选择性药物,并在需要时联合使用β2激动剂如异丙肾上腺素。这样的治疗不太可能导致气道阻力出现麻烦的增加,并且β2激动剂的支气管扩张作用将几乎完全保留。