Mazumdar S, Schimmel H, Higgins I T
Arch Environ Health. 1982 Jul-Aug;37(4):213-20. doi: 10.1080/00039896.1982.10667567.
The relationship between daily deaths and daily concentrations of Smoke and SO2 in London, England for 14 winters during the years 1958-1959 through 1971-1972 has been explored. Three types of analyses were used: (1) year-by-year multiple regression; (2) stratification using nested quartiles of one pollutant within quartiles of the other; and (3) multiple regression of a special subset of high pollution days. An association was found with Smoke, but not with SO2. Whether a linear model with zero threshold or a threshold model best fits could not be determined unambiguously because of a statistical artifact. Reasons for preferring a threshold-type quadratic model are given.
对1958 - 1959年至1971 - 1972年期间英国伦敦14个冬季的每日死亡人数与烟雾和二氧化硫的每日浓度之间的关系进行了探究。采用了三种分析类型:(1)逐年多元回归;(2)在一种污染物的四分位数范围内使用另一种污染物的嵌套四分位数进行分层;(3)对高污染日的一个特殊子集进行多元回归。发现与烟雾有关联,但与二氧化硫没有关联。由于一个统计假象,无法明确确定零阈值线性模型还是阈值模型最适合。给出了倾向于阈值型二次模型的理由。