Goodale R L, Condie R M, Gajl-Peczalska K, Taylor T, O'Leary J, Dressel T, Borner J W, Frick M P, Fryd D S
Ann Surg. 1981 Aug;194(2):193-8. doi: 10.1097/00000658-198108000-00014.
The differential diagnosis between chronic pancreatitis and pancreatic cancer can be very difficult. In 60 patients with either of these conditions, who had satisfactory ERCP study, clinical features were correctly matched with the final diagnosis by discriminant analysis in 44 (73%). The sensitivity of ERCP radiographic findings in pancreatic cancer was 80% and sensitivity of cytology was 54%. To see if exocrine function was specific for cancer, fresh pancreatic secretions were aspirated in 27 patients at the time of ERCP. By isoelectric focusing, a pattern of extreme zymogen depletion was observed in chronic alcoholic pancreatitis (Group 1), pancreatic cancer (Group 2), and chronic nonalcoholic pancreatitis (Group 3). The three groups were not distinguishable. By contrast, significant changes in albumin, IgG and IgA concentrations were seen in Group 2. The albumin level was over ten-fold greater than in Groups 1 and 3 (p less than 0.02 and less than 0.05). The IgG was seven-fold and two-fold greater (p less than 0.01 and greater than 0.2) and the IgA was 15-fold and six-fold greater (p less than 0.002 and less than 0.05) than in Groups 1 and 3, respectively. The two groups of pancreatitis had similar concentrations of albumin and IgA. The ratio of albumin to IgG was also different in Group 2 from the other groups, suggesting different mechanisms for the appearance of proteins in pancreatic secretions. Nonzymogen protein levels can distinguish chronic pancreatitis from pancreatic cancer, and further study of them may identify useful tumor-specific markers.
慢性胰腺炎与胰腺癌的鉴别诊断可能非常困难。在60例患有这两种疾病之一且ERCP检查结果满意的患者中,通过判别分析,44例(73%)的临床特征与最终诊断正确匹配。胰腺癌患者ERCP影像学表现的敏感性为80%,细胞学检查的敏感性为54%。为了观察外分泌功能是否对癌症具有特异性,在27例患者进行ERCP时采集了新鲜的胰腺分泌物。通过等电聚焦法,在慢性酒精性胰腺炎(第1组)、胰腺癌(第2组)和慢性非酒精性胰腺炎(第3组)中均观察到一种极端的酶原消耗模式。这三组无法区分。相比之下,第2组中白蛋白、IgG和IgA浓度有显著变化。第2组的白蛋白水平比第1组和第3组高出十倍以上(p<0.02和<0.05)。第2组的IgG分别比第1组和第3组高七倍和两倍(p<0.01和>0.2),IgA分别比第1组和第3组高15倍和六倍(p<0.002和<0.05)。两组胰腺炎的白蛋白和IgA浓度相似。第2组中白蛋白与IgG的比值也与其他组不同,提示胰腺分泌物中蛋白质出现的机制不同。非酶原蛋白水平可区分慢性胰腺炎和胰腺癌,对其进一步研究可能会发现有用的肿瘤特异性标志物。