Burki N K, Krumpelman J L
Am Rev Respir Dis. 1980 Feb;121(2):217-23. doi: 10.1164/arrd.1980.121.2.217.
To evaluate the correlation of various roentgenographic indices with airway obstruction, the chest roentgenograms of 189 patients were independently examined (without knowledge of their clinical status or measured pulmonary function) by a pulmonary physician and by a chest radiologist. For most indices, there was a close correlation in the measured results between the 2 observers; the exception was assessment of areas of hyperlucency. Airflow obstruction was best correlated with the level of the right dome of the diaphragm. When this level was at or below the anterior end of the seventh rib, airflow obstruction was almost invariably present (specificity greater than 97%); however, the sensitivity of this index was low (range, 31 to 42%). There was a significant correlation with other roentgenographic indices; however, curvature of the diaphragm and retrosternal space were not as good over-all indices of airflow obstruction as was the level of the right dome of the diaphragm. When the retrosternal space was greater 4.4 cm or the transverse diameter of the heart was less than 11.5 cm, airflow obstruction was almost invariably present; but the sensitivity of these indices was low. In contrast, the presence and extent of areas of hyperlucency were poorly correlated with airflow obstruction. Parahilar bronchi were visualized in less than 50% of the chest roentgenograms by either observer; the ratio of wall thickness to diameter of these bronchi was not well correlated with the degree of airflow obstruction. The results indicate that a good assessment of the presence or absence of airflow obstruction can be made from various features of the chest roentgenogram.
为评估各种X线指标与气道阻塞的相关性,一位肺科医生和一位胸部放射科医生对189例患者的胸部X线片进行了独立检查(不了解其临床状况或测量的肺功能)。对于大多数指标,两位观察者的测量结果密切相关;例外情况是对透亮区面积的评估。气流阻塞与右侧膈穹窿水平相关性最佳。当该水平位于或低于第七肋前端时,气流阻塞几乎总是存在(特异性大于97%);然而,该指标的敏感性较低(范围为31%至42%)。与其他X线指标也存在显著相关性;然而,膈肌曲率和胸骨后间隙作为气流阻塞的总体指标不如右侧膈穹窿水平。当胸骨后间隙大于4.4 cm或心脏横径小于11.5 cm时,气流阻塞几乎总是存在;但这些指标的敏感性较低。相比之下,透亮区的存在和范围与气流阻塞的相关性较差。两位观察者在不到50%的胸部X线片中观察到肺门旁支气管;这些支气管的壁厚与直径之比与气流阻塞程度相关性不佳。结果表明,根据胸部X线片的各种特征可以对气流阻塞的有无做出良好评估。