Horne J A
Biol Psychol. 1978 Sep;7(1-2):55-102. doi: 10.1016/0301-0511(78)90042-x.
This biologically oriented review attempts to complement earlier and more psychological performance based reviews of total sleep deprivation. Also, the effects of total sleep deprivation are interpreted, here, from a function of human sleep perspective, rather than from the more usual stress viewpoint. It would appear that total sleep deprivation does not produce any major changes in biochemical and physiological measures of somatic functioning. Such a conclusion would not seem to support an hypothesis that human sleep is for body restitution. Although there are equivocal results amongst several of the more psychophysiological measures, EEG does show a pronounced change. This latter finding, together with many reports of psychological performance detriment, would appear to sustain a CNS or cerebral restitutional role for human sleep. However, before definitive conclusions can be drawn from the biochemical and physiological findings of total sleep deprivation, the following qualifications of experimental methodology are made: (1) Apart from sleep loss, many studies have provided unnatural regimes which may have ameliorated possible effects of total sleep deprivation. (2) Most studies are of relatively short duration and may not have been sufficiently long for effects to develop. (3) Measures are often limited in range and depth of analysis. (4) Subjects are mostly fit, young adult, intelligent males and there is little constitutional variability. (5) Reported changes of statistical significance may be of no physiological significance and changes of possible physiological significance may be obscured by statistical procedures. (6) Intervening behavioural variables, such as novelty and anticipation of the sleep deprivation situation, may confound real effects.
这篇以生物学为导向的综述旨在补充早期更多基于心理表现的关于完全睡眠剥夺的综述。此外,本文从人类睡眠功能的角度来解释完全睡眠剥夺的影响,而非从更常见的压力视角。似乎完全睡眠剥夺在躯体功能的生化和生理指标上并未产生任何重大变化。这样的结论似乎并不支持人类睡眠是为了身体恢复的假说。尽管在一些心理生理学指标中存在不明确的结果,但脑电图确实显示出明显变化。后一发现,连同许多关于心理表现受损的报告,似乎支持了人类睡眠具有中枢神经系统或大脑恢复功能的观点。然而,在从完全睡眠剥夺的生化和生理研究结果得出明确结论之前,需对实验方法作如下说明:(1)除了睡眠缺失外,许多研究提供的是不自然的状态,这可能减轻了完全睡眠剥夺的潜在影响。(2)大多数研究持续时间相对较短,可能未足够长到使影响得以显现。(3)测量范围和分析深度往往有限。(4)研究对象大多是健康、年轻、成年、聪明的男性,体质差异很小。(5)报告的具有统计学意义的变化可能并无生理意义,而可能具有生理意义的变化可能被统计程序掩盖。(6)诸如新奇感和对睡眠剥夺情境的预期等干预行为变量可能混淆实际效果。