McHale S M, Crouter A C, McGuire S A, Updegraff K A
College of Health and Human Development, Penn State University, University Park 16802, USA.
Child Dev. 1995 Feb;66(1):116-28. doi: 10.1111/j.1467-8624.1995.tb00859.x.
We studied patterns of mothers' and fathers' differential treatment of firstborn (average age 10.5 years) and secondborn (average age 8 years) school-age siblings, and we examined the links between parents' differential treatment and children's well-being and dyadic family relationships. Mothers, fathers, and both siblings in 110 families were interviewed in their homes. For each dimension of parental behavior that we assessed (i.e., differential affection and discipline) we created groups of families that reflected mothers' and fathers' levels of differential treatment (e.g., discipline the firstborn more, equal treatment, discipline the secondborn more). Although we detected substantial correspondence between the 2 parents' differential treatment, we found a sizable group of families in which parents' reports were incongruent (i.e., 1 parent reported equal and the other differential treatment). Parental patterns were linked to differences between the siblings' well-being and both sibling and parent-child relationships, with younger siblings exhibiting greater vulnerability to differential treatment. Incongruence in differential warmth was associated with marital distress.
我们研究了父母对学龄期头胎子女(平均年龄10.5岁)和二胎子女(平均年龄8岁)区别对待的模式,并考察了父母区别对待与子女幸福感及家庭二元关系之间的联系。我们对110个家庭中的母亲、父亲以及两个孩子都进行了家访。对于我们评估的父母行为的每个维度(即区别关爱和管教),我们将家庭分为几组,以反映母亲和父亲的区别对待程度(例如,对老大管教更多、平等对待、对老二管教更多)。虽然我们发现父母的区别对待之间存在相当大的一致性,但我们也发现有相当一部分家庭中父母的报告不一致(即一方报告平等对待,另一方报告区别对待)。父母的模式与兄弟姐妹幸福感的差异以及兄弟姐妹和亲子关系都有关联,年幼的兄弟姐妹对区别对待表现出更大的脆弱性。区别温暖方面的不一致与婚姻困扰有关。