Dietrich W, Dilthey G, Spannagl M, Jochum M, Braun S L, Richter J A
Department of Anesthesiology, German Heart Center, Munich, Germany.
Anesthesiology. 1995 Oct;83(4):679-89; discussion 29A-30A. doi: 10.1097/00000542-199510000-00006.
Aprotinin causes a prolongation of the celite-activated clotting time (CACT), but not of the kaolin-activated clotting time (KACT). Therefore, concern has been raised regarding the reliability of CACT to monitor anticoagulation in the presence of aprotinin. The current study was designed to test the efficacy of aprotinin to improve anticoagulation, and to investigate whether the prolongation of CACT reflects true anticoagulation or is an in vitro artifact. To elucidate this antithrombotic effect of aprotinin, this study was done in patients prone to reduced intraoperative heparin sensitivity.
In a prospective, randomized, double-blind clinical trial, 30 male patients scheduled for elective primary coronary revascularization and treated with heparin for at least 10 days preoperatively, received either high-dose aprotinin (group A) or placebo (group C). The CACT and KACT were determined, but only CACT was used to control anticoagulation with heparin. Parameters of coagulation that are indicators of thrombin generation and activity (F1+2 prothrombin fragments, thrombin-antithrombin III complex, and fibrin monomers), parameters of fibrinolysis (D-dimers), aprotinin, and heparin plasma concentrations were measured. Postoperative blood loss and allogeneic blood transfused were recorded.
Total heparin administered was 36,200 units (95% confidence interval: 31,400-41,000; group C) compared with 27,700 (25,500-29,800) units (group A; P < 0.05). Hemostatic activation during cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB) was significantly reduced in group A compared with group C. After 60 min of CPB, all parameters were significantly different (P < 0.05) between the groups (group C vs. group A): F1+2 prothrombin fragments, 9.7 (8.9-11.7) ng/ml versus 7.5 (6.2-8.6) ng/ml; thrombin-anti-thrombin III complex (TAT), 53 (42-68) ng/ml versus 29 (23-38) ng/ml; and fibrin monomers, 23 (12-43) ng/ml versus 8 (3-17) ng/ml. Fibrinolysis was also attenuated; D-dimers at the end of operation were 656 (396-1,089) and 2,710 (1,811-4,055) ng/ml for groups A and C, respectively (P < 0.05). The CACT 5 min after the onset of CPB was 552 (485-627) versus 869 (793-955) s for groups C and A, respectively (P < 0.05), whereas the KACT showed no differences between the groups (569 [481-675] vs. 614 [541-697] s for groups C and A, respectively; P = NS). The 24-h blood loss was 1,496 (1,125-1,995) versus 597 (448-794) ml for groups C and A, respectively (P < 0.05).
Aprotinin treatment in combination with heparin leads to less thrombin generation during CPB. Aprotinin has anticoagulant properties. Celite-activated ACT is reliable for monitoring anticoagulation in the presence of aprotinin, because the prolonged CACT in the aprotinin group reflects improved anticoagulation. Kaolin-activated ACT does not reflect this effect of aprotinin.
抑肽酶可使硅藻土激活凝血时间(CACT)延长,但不影响高岭土激活凝血时间(KACT)。因此,有人对在使用抑肽酶的情况下,CACT监测抗凝作用的可靠性提出了质疑。本研究旨在测试抑肽酶改善抗凝的效果,并研究CACT延长是反映了真正的抗凝作用还是一种体外假象。为阐明抑肽酶的这种抗血栓形成作用,本研究纳入了术中肝素敏感性降低倾向的患者。
在一项前瞻性、随机、双盲临床试验中,30例计划进行择期原发性冠状动脉血运重建且术前至少接受肝素治疗10天的男性患者,分别接受高剂量抑肽酶(A组)或安慰剂(C组)治疗。测定了CACT和KACT,但仅用CACT来控制肝素抗凝。检测了凝血酶生成和活性的指标(F1+2凝血酶原片段、凝血酶-抗凝血酶III复合物和纤维蛋白单体)、纤溶指标(D-二聚体)、抑肽酶和肝素血浆浓度。记录术后失血量和异体输血量。
C组肝素总用量为36,200单位(95%置信区间:31,400 - 41,000;C组),A组为27,700(25,500 - 29,800)单位(A组;P < 0.05)。与C组相比,A组体外循环(CPB)期间的止血激活显著降低。CPB 60分钟后,两组间所有参数均有显著差异(P < 0.05)(C组与A组):F1+2凝血酶原片段,9.7(8.9 - 11.7)ng/ml对7.5(6.2 - 8.6)ng/ml;凝血酶-抗凝血酶III复合物(TAT),53(42 - 68)ng/ml对29(23 - 38)ng/ml;纤维蛋白单体,23(12 - 43)ng/ml对8(3 - 17)ng/ml。纤溶也减弱;手术结束时A组和C组的D-二聚体分别为656(396 - 1,089)和2,710(1,811 - 4,055)ng/ml(P < 0.05)。CPB开始5分钟后,C组和A组的CACT分别为552(485 - 627)秒和869(793 - 955)秒(P < 0.05),而两组间KACT无差异(C组和A组分别为569 [481 - 675]秒和614 [541 - 697]秒;P = 无显著性差异)。C组和A组24小时失血量分别为1,496(1,125 - 1,995)毫升和597(448 - 794)毫升(P < 0.05)。
抑肽酶与肝素联合治疗可减少CPB期间的凝血酶生成。抑肽酶具有抗凝特性。在使用抑肽酶的情况下,硅藻土激活的活化凝血时间(ACT)可可靠地监测抗凝,因为抑肽酶组CACT延长反映了抗凝改善。高岭土激活的ACT不能反映抑肽酶的这种作用。