Achenbach T M, Howell C T, Aoki M F, Rauh V A
Dept of Psychiatry, University of Vermont, Burlington 05401-1195.
Pediatrics. 1993 Jan;91(1):45-55.
Twenty-four low birth weight children who had received an experimental intervention (LBWE) during the neonatal period, 31 control children who had received no treatment (LBWC), and 36 normal birth weight children were compared. The intervention involved seven hospital sessions and four home sessions in which a nurse helped mothers adapt to their LBW babies. At age 9, LBWE children scored significantly higher than LBWC children on the Kaufman Mental Processing Composite, Sequential, Simultaneous, Achievement, Arithmetic, and Riddles scales, after statistical adjustments for socioeconomic status. The LBWE children had also advanced more rapidly in school than had LBWC children. Parent (Child Behavior Checklist) and teacher (Teacher's Report Form) ratings of school functioning were more favorable for LBWE than LBWC children, with especially strong effects on Teacher's Report Form scores for academic performance and the attention problems syndrome. At age 9, LBWE children were not significantly inferior to normal birth weight children on any measure. These results bear out a progressive divergence between the LBWE and LBWC children that first became statistically significant in cognitive scores at age 3. The findings suggest that the intervention prevented cognitive lags among LBW children and that this eventually had a favorable effect on academic achievement, behavior, and advancement in school. The progression from no significant differences between LBWE and LBWC children on early cognitive and achievement scores to significant and pervasive differences in later functioning argues for long-term follow-up periods to evaluate properly the power of behavioral interventions to compensate for biological risks.
对24名在新生儿期接受过实验性干预的低出生体重儿童(LBWE)、31名未接受过治疗的对照儿童(LBWC)和36名正常出生体重儿童进行了比较。干预包括七次医院疗程和四次家庭疗程,期间一名护士帮助母亲们适应她们的低出生体重婴儿。在9岁时,在对社会经济地位进行统计调整后,LBWE儿童在考夫曼心理加工综合量表、序列量表、同时性量表、成就量表、算术量表和谜语量表上的得分显著高于LBWC儿童。LBWE儿童在学业上的进步也比LBWC儿童更快。家长(儿童行为检查表)和教师(教师报告表)对学校功能的评分显示,LBWE儿童比LBWC儿童更有利,对教师报告表中学习成绩和注意力问题综合征得分的影响尤为显著。在9岁时,LBWE儿童在任何指标上都不比正常出生体重儿童明显差。这些结果证实了LBWE儿童和LBWC儿童之间的逐渐差异,这种差异在3岁时的认知分数上首次具有统计学意义。研究结果表明,该干预措施预防了低出生体重儿童的认知滞后,最终对学业成绩、行为和学业进步产生了积极影响。从LBWE儿童和LBWC儿童在早期认知和成绩分数上无显著差异,到后期功能上出现显著且普遍的差异,这一过程表明需要长期随访来正确评估行为干预措施补偿生物学风险的能力。