Thiel A, Schüssler G
Abteilung Psychiatrie, Georg-August-Universität Göttingen.
Z Psychosom Med Psychoanal. 1995;41(1):60-76.
The present study reports findings concerning the hypothesis whether patients with narcissistic self-system disturbances show more obsessive-compulsive (OC) symptoms as compared to patients without such disturbances. Ninety-one patients meeting DSM-III-R criteria for anorexia nervosa (AN) or bulimia nervosa (BN) were investigated using the Narzissmusinventar (NI), the Hamburger-Zwangsinventar (HZI), the Yale-Brown Obsessive Compulsive Scale (Y-BOCS) and the Eating Disorder Inventory (EDI). The NI-data demonstrated a great variance of self-system disturbances in AN and BN; a cluster analysis identified two different clinical features. In comparison to eating disorder patients without concomitant disturbances of the self-system (n = 34) the patient group with such narcissistic deficits (n = 57) showed significantly higher Y-BOCS and HZI-scores indicating more and severer OC symptoms. These patients also had significantly higher and hence pathologic means on seven of eight EDI scales. The results suggest that OC behaviour may be an unconscious attempt to stabilize the self-system equilibrium, i.e. counteracting narcisstic desintegration. Regulatory processes of the self-system and OC symptoms may present additional prognostic factors and lead to new approaches in psychotherapy research.
与没有自恋自我系统障碍的患者相比,患有自恋自我系统障碍的患者是否表现出更多的强迫症状。使用自恋量表(NI)、汉堡强迫量表(HZI)、耶鲁-布朗强迫量表(Y-BOCS)和进食障碍量表(EDI)对91名符合《精神疾病诊断与统计手册》第三版修订版(DSM-III-R)中神经性厌食症(AN)或神经性贪食症(BN)标准的患者进行了调查。NI数据显示,AN和BN患者的自我系统障碍存在很大差异;聚类分析确定了两种不同的临床特征。与没有伴随自我系统障碍的进食障碍患者(n = 34)相比,患有自恋缺陷的患者组(n = 57)的Y-BOCS和HZI得分显著更高,表明强迫症状更多、更严重。这些患者在EDI八个量表中的七个量表上的平均分也显著更高,因此属于病态。结果表明,强迫行为可能是一种稳定自我系统平衡的无意识尝试,即对抗自恋解体。自我系统的调节过程和强迫症状可能是额外的预后因素,并导致心理治疗研究的新方法。