Tsyb A F, Vtyurin B M
Medical Radiological Research Centre, Kaluga Region, Russia.
Analyst. 1995 Mar;120(3):817-21. doi: 10.1039/an9952000817.
To evaluate the importance of trace amounts of elements in thyroid cancer etiology and diagnostics, instrumental neutron activation analysis has been used to estimate Ag, Co, Cr, Fe, Hg, I,Rb, Sb, Sc, Se, and Zn concentrations in malignant and benign thyroid nodules as well as in apparently intact paranodular thyroid tissue. Resected material from 135 patients was obtained from operations. Forty-five cancer cases were diagnosed and the rest were of benign nodules. The thyroid glands of 65 people, 53 male and 12 female, who died and unexpected death or committed suicide, were used as a control group. Trace element contents of the International Atomic Energy Agency reference material H-4 (animal muscle) were analysed simultaneously with the thyroid tissue in order to evaluate the accuracy of the obtained data. No dependence of trace element contents on sex and age (14-80 years) was found for normal thyroids. In paranodular tissue, the Ag, Co, Hg, I and Rb contents were much higher for malignant and benign nodules than they were for the standard. There was also a slight deficiency of Se in the nodules compared with the standard. This result supports the hypothesis that the direct toxic heavy metal influence on thyrocytes plays a major role in thyroid cancer etiology, provided that an adequate level of the defence mechanisms is absent. Iodine concentrations are 15 times lower, on average, in malignant compared with benign nodules. It is also shown that the radio between the iodine concentration in nodular and paranodular tissue can be used for in vivo thyroid cancer diagnostics.
为评估微量元素在甲状腺癌病因学和诊断中的重要性,采用仪器中子活化分析法测定了恶性和良性甲状腺结节以及明显完整的结节旁甲状腺组织中银、钴、铬、铁、汞、碘、铷、锑、钪、硒和锌的浓度。从135例患者的手术切除物中获取样本。其中45例为癌症病例,其余为良性结节。将65例因意外死亡或自杀死亡者(53例男性,12例女性)的甲状腺作为对照组。为评估所获数据的准确性,将甲状腺组织与国际原子能机构参考物质H-4(动物肌肉)的微量元素含量同时进行分析。对于正常甲状腺,未发现微量元素含量与性别和年龄(14 - 80岁)有关。在结节旁组织中,恶性和良性结节中的银、钴、汞、碘和铷含量均远高于标准值。与标准值相比,结节中的硒含量也略有不足。这一结果支持了如下假说:在缺乏足够防御机制的情况下,直接的有毒重金属对甲状腺细胞的影响在甲状腺癌病因学中起主要作用。恶性结节中的碘浓度平均比良性结节低15倍。研究还表明,结节组织和结节旁组织中的碘浓度之比可用于甲状腺癌的体内诊断。