Verhoef M J, Sutherland L R
Department of Community Health Sciences, Faculty of Medicine, University of Calgary.
Can Fam Physician. 1995 Jun;41:1005-11.
To describe general practitioners' opinions and behaviour regarding alternative medicine.
Cross-sectional survey of a random sample of Ontario and Alberta general practitioners.
General practices in Ontario and Alberta.
A questionnaire was mailed to 400 general practitioners. Of the 384 eligible physicians, 200 completed the questionnaire.
Reported beliefs and practices concerning alternative medicine.
Acupuncture, chiropractic, and hypnosis were considered most useful and reflexology, naturopathy, and homeopathy least useful. Results showed 56% of general practitioners believed that alternative medicine has ideas and methods from which conventional medicine could benefit, 54% referred to alternative practitioners, and 16% practised some form of alternative medicine. Province of practice, place of graduation, training in alternative approaches, number of alternative approaches perceived useful, and attitude toward alternative medicine were clearly related to referring to alternative practitioners. Sex, age, type of practice, training in alternative medicine, referring to alternative practitioners, number of alternative approaches perceived useful, and attitude toward alternative medicine were related to practicing alternative medicine.
Although acceptance and integration of alternative medicine extend only to certain approaches, alternative medicine cannot be discounted in general practice. A study encompassing all Canadian provinces could help in planning medical education and developing policies to guide physician behaviour.
描述全科医生对替代医学的看法和行为。
对安大略省和艾伯塔省全科医生的随机样本进行横断面调查。
安大略省和艾伯塔省的普通诊所。
向400名全科医生邮寄了问卷。在384名符合条件的医生中,200名完成了问卷。
报告的关于替代医学的信念和行为。
针灸、整脊疗法和催眠被认为最有用,而反射疗法、自然疗法和顺势疗法最没用。结果显示,56%的全科医生认为替代医学有一些理念和方法可供传统医学借鉴,54%的医生会推荐患者去看替代医学从业者,16%的医生会采用某种形式的替代医学。执业省份、毕业地点、接受替代医学方法的培训、认为有用的替代医学方法的数量以及对替代医学的态度与推荐患者去看替代医学从业者明显相关。性别、年龄、执业类型、接受替代医学培训、推荐患者去看替代医学从业者、认为有用的替代医学方法的数量以及对替代医学的态度与采用替代医学相关。
尽管对替代医学的接受和整合仅局限于某些方法,但在全科医疗中不能忽视替代医学。一项涵盖加拿大所有省份的研究有助于规划医学教育并制定指导医生行为的政策。