MacDonald V M, Tsiantis J, Achenbach T M, Motti-Stefanidi F, Richardson S C
Department of Psychiatry, University of Vermont 05401, USA.
Eur Child Adolesc Psychiatry. 1995 Jan;4(1):1-13. doi: 10.1007/BF01987961.
This study compared parent-reported competencies and behavioral/emotional problems in demographically-matched samples of Greek and American children, ages 6-11. Parents of 356 children of each nationality completed the Child Behavior Checklist (CBCL). Competence scores were higher for American children, except on Academic Competence, where scores were higher for Greek children. Greek scores were significantly higher than American scores on the Withdrawn, Anxious/Depressed, Attention Problems, Delinquent Behavior, Aggressive Behavior, Internalizing, Externalizing, and Total Problem scales. On the Anxious/Depressed syndrome, nationality accounted for 14% of the variance. There were few main effects for sex and age and fewer interactions. The higher problem scores in the Greek sample were partly due to the tendency of Greek parents to use extreme item scores. When items were scored present v. absent, Greek scores were higher only on Withdrawn, Anxious/Depressed, Internalizing, and Total Problems, while American scores were higher on Somatic Complaints and Thought Problems. Nationality differences in rates of referral for mental health services and sample differences in exclusion criteria for prior mental health services may have contributed to differences in problem scores. Results are compared to findings from other cross-cultural studies.
本研究比较了年龄在6至11岁、人口统计学特征匹配的希腊儿童和美国儿童样本中,家长报告的能力以及行为/情绪问题。每个国籍的356名儿童的家长完成了儿童行为量表(CBCL)。美国儿童的能力得分较高,但学业能力方面除外,希腊儿童在该方面得分更高。在退缩、焦虑/抑郁、注意力问题、违纪行为、攻击行为、内化问题、外化问题和总问题量表上,希腊儿童的得分显著高于美国儿童。在焦虑/抑郁综合征方面,国籍因素占方差的14%。性别和年龄的主效应较少,交互作用也较少。希腊样本中较高的问题得分部分归因于希腊家长倾向于使用极端的项目得分。当项目按存在与否计分,希腊儿童仅在退缩、焦虑/抑郁、内化问题和总问题方面得分较高,而美国儿童在躯体主诉和思维问题方面得分较高。心理健康服务转诊率的国籍差异以及先前心理健康服务排除标准的样本差异可能导致了问题得分的差异。研究结果与其他跨文化研究的发现进行了比较。